COllaborative DEcision MAking (codema.in)

Missing top priority features in Organic Maps and GNOME Maps

Pirate Praveen Tue 24 Sep 2024 12:34PMPublicSeen by 19

Introduce and describe the topic

Organic Maps came first in the apps poll and GNOME Maps was a very close second. https://codema.in/d/phU1JlaV/pick-and-fund-a-maps-app

So we need to list out the missing top priority features in both apps. We can try to crowd fund missing features in at least one app (may be both apps).

Why is this important?

We need this to provide good Maps/Navigation experience.

How would you like people to respond?

Add the missing features of both apps (features that came at the top in this poll https://codema.in/d/lvQjiUo6/ideal-maps-navigation-app-features will have a higher priority)

Pirate PraveenTue 24 Sep 2024 12:43PM

Organic Maps:

  1. Adapt to mobile screen - https://github.com/orgs/organicmaps/discussions/6420

  2. (low priority) load and record GPS tracks

GNOME Maps:

  1. Offline Maps - https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gnome-maps/-/issues/416

  2. Turn by Turn Navigation - https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/gnome-maps/-/issues/335

  3. Some UI/UX improvements (we have to make a list, I think bigger buttons would be one)

  4. (low priority) load and record GPS tracks

baarkerloungerTue 24 Sep 2024 4:12PM

Given that:

  • Gnome Map's main advantage over Organic Maps is that it's GTK based

  • Organic Maps is a common C++ core with various frontend's (currently Java, Swift, QT?)

  • The QT frontend is far from parity with the others

Does it maybe make sense to try to fund development of a GTK frontend for Organic Maps?

This assumes of course that building that front end would be less work than trying to implement all the core features Organic Maps already has in Gnome Maps.

Badri SunderarajanMon 6 Jan 2025 4:32PM

Organic Maps has received NLNet funding to develop a touch-friendly version (using Qt Quick/Kirigami).

https://nlnet.nl/project/OrganicMaps-ConvergentUI/

Maybe not the best possible outcome (because not GTK) but I would say it's the second-best, as we will get a fully functional map app that works well with a touchscreen and has all (most?) of the existing Organic Maps features!