Associate Requests
Those who want to be an Associate can add their requests here. You have to publicly state your acceptance of the constitution (http://pirates.org.in/constitution)
Associates needs only accepting the constitution. If you disagree with any of the points in the constitution, we can discuss it here as well.
If you are an associate for at least 6 months and at least 2 members know about your work (they have to vouch for you), you can request to be a member here -> https://codema.in/d/gmu9B3YH
More details about rights of associates and members is specified in the constitution.
Next Steps
Please introduce yourself here -> https://codema.in/d/4Cpz3YGn/ after applying and
join this sub group (so its easy to track associates) -> https://codema.in/g/zINlUo6f/indian-pirates-associates (and any other sub groups that excites you).
I, Fayad Fami accept the constitution mentioned under http://www.pirates.org.in/constitution/ and would like to take part in the Pirate Movement by being an initial member. Please do the needful.
I have read and accept the constitution. I would like to be an Initial Member. I would also like to propose the addition of the right to energy in Article 1, Section 3 of the constitution.
@naveenkumar welcome as an Associate Member. @akshay welcome as an Initial Member, now propose those amendments! Also we need to make membership requests easier, me and @balasankarchelamat were discussing a form based membership process.
@arjun you can see them at https://codema.in/g/7qmru1SG/memberships
I accept the constitution in its spirit and want to apply for Associate membership.
@praveenarimbrathod hey! Where can I go check our groups list of members?
@naveenkumar state your acceptance to constitution here for the record.
@akshay laws are always made for the powerful in any society and there was always struggles to change any unjust laws. Look at slavery, it was legal when Martin Luther King opposed it, even making salt from sea water was illegal in British rule. Criticizing British rule was illegal as well. As Aaron Swartz rightly said, there is no justice in following unjust laws. But we will use non violent ways to achieve our goals of changing the copyright system. So we can clearly state, it is our goal to change the copyright laws so that sharing knowledge is not illegal. See Pirates are already winning in Europe http://torrentfreak.com/in-europe-pirates-are-writing-the-copyright-law-150104/
I concur that copying is not theft. And making some knowledge public can be greatly beneficial for the humanity.
But like I said, I cannot wrap my head around copying something against someone's will. That is essentially violation of their privacy. I can definitely see it as a violent mean to achieve political aims.
Analogies:
Wearing of burqas or veil. It will be violent if someone forcibly removes those veils.
Consent in vaccination, treatment, etc. It is violent if you vaccinate someone, or treat someone against their wish, even though it is healthy for them to undergo treatment.
Okay, these analogies are not perfect if you consider that the publishers had no right to keep the knowledge with them.
Then a better analogy would be zamindars or landholders.
Would it be right to rob them? Maybe.
But that'll necessarily cause some mental trauma to the zamindar.
Would that trauma be justified, because the zamindar doesn't have the right to the grains? Not sure.
But copying is not theft. Probably this concept is very new and originated only after computers came up. So the public perception of copying being equivalent to theft is or could be wrong.
Still the existing laws consider copying a punishable offence. These laws have to be changed obviously. Yet they are formed by a democratic body. And they need to be respected while they prevail.
Maybe we should just stay away from leading "illegal" activities. For the sake of political correctness.
@akshay you can propose those changes if one more member supports your membership request.
@akshay First of all knowledge cannot be considered the same as physical property. When you copy knowledge the original is not lost. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IeTybKL1pM4
The act of hiding knowledge that can benefit humanity is the violence here. All the scientific knowledge locked up by publishers is shared heritage of entire humanity.
Since cooperation by itself is not our aim, it should be expanded to something more like "We should cooperate with each other for the benefit of humanity" or something that clarifies when the cooperation is warranted. Because obviously there can't be cooperation in negative activities.
For knowledge,
Maybe mix in ideas frm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Libre_knowledge
We should be creating knowledge that is Libre knowledge, and we should be lobbying on existing knowledge "owners" to make them liberate the knowledge that they conceal from others.
To be specific, I still haven't gotten my head around the ethicality of downloading articles against the wish or intent of publishers. And since this is akin to violence (although not physical) which we are against in section 6, there should be no support of "pirating" knowledge as in the Geurilla Manifesto.
If those suggestions seems reasonable, consider my concerns cleared and accept my application to be a member.
@akshay historically, it was "All humans are equal. We should cooperate with each other". We updated the first part and we should clarify the second part. Suggest new wordings that can better explain the cooperation spirit.
@akshay we means all humans, and section 4 is Knowledge should be free. We are in the process of clarifying each statement so we can still discuss and improve the wordings.
There has been lots of amendments to clarify each statement recently, see https://codema.in/g/rBujPIAJ/indian-pirates-initial-members
Last two amendments are yet to be updated on the site.
I accept the constitution in its spirit and want to apply for initial membership pending the following clarifications on the basic principles:
Section 2: "We should cooperate with each other"
Who are the "we" here? How is cooperation defined? Is it absolute and mandatory?
Section 4: "Education should be free"
What is the definition of "free" here?
I agree to the constitution.. I'd like to join the movement.. Honestly I don't really know much about computers and networks.. Just the basic stuff a layman would know.. I have been following the various issues surrounding Internet privacy.. I stand for Internet freedom..
I won't be able to be a full time member because of the nature of my work and I don't really know how I could be useful.. But I do wanna do something useful and I'm so glad there are like minded people in India..
Really looking Forward to be a member and do something.. Anything useful for the movement..
Thanks
@neelgupta you can request membership to associate members group. Once we work together some of us would be able to support your full membership request. We can discuss about equality over here https://codema.in/d/sAa2Im3E/equality
I agree to the constitution as is.
(I advocate Freedom and Respect for freedom of others, instead of Equality.)
@neelgupta , you have to state you agree with the constitution and get support from two existing initial members to be an initial member. You can become an associate member straight away if you agree to the constitution. We are working on making the membership experience smoother. You can also help complete it at https://gitlab.com/piratemovin/beapirate
The membership request form should ask the following details about the person: name, email, phone (optional)
Then we should frame questions on each of our core ideas and see if they really agree to our constitution or not. Many times people just click I agree without reading anything.
If we find out differences during the survey, we should add them as potential members and ask them to discuss the differences with us. If either of us change our opinions they can be a member. It would be a good real world test of our constitution too.
I have started a project - https://gitlab.com/piratemovin/beapirate
@akshaytarfe you have to state your agreement to the constitution http://www.pirates.org.in/constitution/
If you have any disagreements with any of the points, we can discuss them here.
We would also like provide a smooth experience for folks interested to join us by providing a web registration form.
@balasankarchelamat start a project on our gitlab area and we can discuss details here.
hey its akshay , geography and political science student from Mumbai . Looking forward to work with you guys. Believe that another world is possible. so support my membership and lets get to work
cheers. peace out
@akshaytarfe you have to apply for membership here and you need support from two other initial members, you can also join as an associate member.
@rajudvindane , welcome! You are an initial member now.
@shirish you are an initial member now... Welcome.. :)
@arkarjun you are an initial member now! welcome! @praveenarimbrathod Can we have two proposals at same time in the same discussion?if it is ok, then @arkarjun can make a proposal for @rajudvindane
@balasankarchelamat i'll close the Ark's proposal., you can start one for @shirish . :)
@praveenarimbrathod Can we have two proposals at same time in the same discussion? I couldn't find it. Lets close the one for Ark first, then I'll start one for Shirish. :)
I राजु देविदास विंदाने (Raju Devidas Vindane) has read & understood the constitution of the Pirates Movement. I affirm that I agree to the Constitution and request to be an initial member of the Pirates Movement of India.
@rajudvindane , you have to publicly state your acceptance of constitution and get support from 2 other initial members to be an initial member.
@balasankarchelamat please propose a vote for accepting Shirish as an initial member.
@balasankarchelamat you are an initial member now! welcome!
I,arjun , have read, understood and agree to the constitution of the Pirate Movement and would like to join the movement as an Initial Member as well.
I, shirish, have read, understood and agree to the constitution of the Pirate Movement and would like to join the movement as an Initial Member as well.
@suneesh you are an initial member now! welcome! Create a proposal to accept @balasankarchelamat as initial member.
I, Balasankar C, have read, understood and agree to the constitution of Pirate Movement and would like to join the movement as an Initial Member.
Yes I agree to the constitution
@suneesh say if you agree to the constitution or not. Once two initial members approve, you'll become an initial member.
i am suneesh states that from now i am a part of the pirate movement of india, and also initial member of the pirate movement of india
@suneesh please state your acceptance of constitution here.
@vik you are an initial member now! Welcome!
@fayadfami you need two initial members to vouch for you. Once you actively involve in campaigns you will find people to vouch for you. Right now you can be an associate member.