COllaborative DEcision MAking (codema.in)

Associate Requests

Pirate Praveen PublicSeen by 1056

Those who want to be an Associate can add their requests here. You have to publicly state your acceptance of the constitution (http://pirates.org.in/constitution)

Associates needs only accepting the constitution. If you disagree with any of the points in the constitution, we can discuss it here as well.

If you are an associate for at least 6 months and at least 2 members know about your work (they have to vouch for you), you can request to be a member here -> https://codema.in/d/gmu9B3YH

More details about rights of associates and members is specified in the constitution.

Next Steps


  1. Please introduce yourself here -> https://codema.in/d/4Cpz3YGn/ after applying and

  2. join this sub group (so its easy to track associates) -> https://codema.in/g/zINlUo6f/indian-pirates-associates (and any other sub groups that excites you).

Pirate Praveen

Balu, do you believe luck, fate or karma from previous incarnation should be the basis for one's status and opportunities in life?

Balasankar C

Not completely. Some portions of it suck. Like forceful wealth acquisition, just coz the other guy need it too. Pirate Movement is not another face of pure socialism. It adopts from socialism (and many other good -isms).

I vote for "equal opportunity" rather than "equal right". But, providing equal opportunity is somewhat utopian and needs a well-defined-well-planned-well-executed-long-term-course-of-action and we may need a temporary solution to start with. But, finally, that is my (AFAIK, our) aim and so it should be made clear in the constitution.

Akshay

Basically, you're saying socialism sucks.

Balasankar C

//Nobody is taking your money and giving it to someone else.
What is redistributed is opportunity. They take your money and distribute it as opportunity to those who are deprived of it.//

Err.. Aren't those two contradicting each other?? Do I pay money or opportunity?? If it is opportunity, do I lose my job inorder to give the other guy an opportunity?? If it is money, where is my compensation for you taking my money for something I don't agree to?

//Laziness is not the eligibility to get help from the Government. Opportunity deprivation is.//

And is it solved by "exploiting" my opportunity?

// After a limit, if you’re earning more money, you’re not going to be able to use it. And therefore there is no actual point in you making that money. And so, in the big picture, it is better for that money to be redistributed. //

Are we playing digital Robin Hood?? I decide whether the money created by my effort is useful or useless. Not the government.. Government don't own me. If I see the taxes they levy as valid, I pay them. Else, I don't. And I am ready to give up the services which I would've received if I had paid those taxes. But for that, I need clarity. Clarity on how the tax I pay is spent. Whether it is spent on an idea that I agree to.

Akshay

  • Nobody is taking your money and giving it to someone else.
  • What is redistributed is opportunity. They take your money and distribute it as opportunity to those who are deprived of it.
  • Laziness is not the eligibility to get help from the Government. Opportunity deprivation is.
  • After a limit, if you're earning more money, you're not going to be able to use it. And therefore there is no actual point in you making that money. And so, in the big picture, it is better for that money to be redistributed.

Balasankar C

Blunt levying of taxes, just for the sake of "equality" is what I am opposing. Taxation should be properly transparent and categorized. The income tax I pay is being used to "provide equality of food" is not something I agree with. It was levied for the services I get w.r.t the sector from where I earn that income. So, it should be channelled to that sector itself. This should happen for every sector, thereby making each of them self-sufficient.
Making every goddamn sector self sufficient is the ultimate goal of a government, not providing till the end of eternity.
You want to provide food to the poor? Take it out of the tax you levy from the food production sector. Make a cycle.

Jemshid's question remains - If I find out the tax I am paying is used for ideas that I disagree with, do I have the option to stay out of paying "that" tax (and thereby excluding myself from enjoying the services which that idea provides) and still enjoy the other services, for which I pay tax for??

Akshay

Taxation is the foundation of the constitution. There's no Government that lives without taxes. You can't disagree with that part.

Balasankar C

BTW, what happened to the discussion that @jemshidkk started and @praveen @vik and @akshay followed?? I was enjoying it and it abruptly stopped.

Actually, I am in support of Jemshid's side (even though I wish to see Praveen's idea in execution one day - however utopian it may seem. Afterall we are all working towards to get a future where it will be implemented right?). Other person's right to have food should not mean the food (or part of it) I have is taken from me and given to him. I earned my food (I am not talking about using my Dad's money to buy food - I put effort to make my food) and it is primarly and ultimately my right. If the other guy wants food, he should not be given the food which was taken from me. But, he should be made able to produce his own food (or something - product or service - which he can exchange to get food). You don't get a man a fish, you teach him how to catch one.
If he/she is unable to do that due to his conditions or societiy's inequal mindset or something like that, change the damn society. Change the damn system. The society, being harsh to him/her in accomplishing his needs is no reason to infringe in the product of my work.

Yes, the society does not play fair and equal. But, when you force me to share the product of my work with someone who don't have product (whatever the reason may be), it ain't democracy. It is just majoritarianism.

Yes. I used the knowledge of the previous generations to cultivate food. Due to that I am ready to share my food - but not for free. I want reward for my efforts - I tilled the land, I sowed the seeds, I watered it - I did everything (or I paid to get it done. Anyway it was essentially my wealth that was spent). You want a piece of it? Then pay me for my effort dumbass. Period.

Also, I don't agree to @akshay 's arguments. Just because I dissent from the provisions of constitution doesn't mean I am out of the structure. I simply disagree to follow the portions that I feel improper. That just means I can't exercise that provisions either. But, I have equal rights to exercise the provisions of constitution that I abide to. It ain't the "whole or nothing business".

A gun doesn't mean a physical gun. Just the threatening of "Either you agree to the constitution in whole, or you may dissent and live alone" is also a gun, a figurative one.

Balasankar C

I would like to apply for permanent membership. I was an initial member, both here at Indian Pirates and its previous installation - Pirate Party of India. I have been a part in the discussions which shaped our constitution. Also, I have helped in the initial organizing of Diaspora Yatra, along with Anish and Sugeesh. I have also helped share the essence of Diaspora by taking classes about Diaspora in educational institutions like CUSAT.

shine

@akshay, @praveenarimbrathod : thank you for accepting me into the pack of pirates. Happy to be here. :-)

Pirate Praveen

@shine welcome as an associate member. As @akshay mentioned initial members are used only for bootatraping. You can be a permanent member after 6 months if you get support from 2 voting members. Stating acceptance to constitution is the only requirement to be an associate member.

Akshay

@shine Initial Membership was used for bootstrapping and now that we've some permanent members it is no longer required. I am considering your request as a request for associate membership and putting it to vote here. If 2 voting members agree you'll become an associate member.

shine

I, shine, have read, understood and agree to the constitution of Pirate Movement and would like to join the movement as an Initial Member

Akshay

@praveenarimbrathod you're now a permanent member. I've added you to the voting members subgroup.

Long live the revolution! ;)

Pirate Praveen

I would like to be a permanent member. I was an initial member (including two previous experiments of Pirate Movement and Pirate Party) and promoted pirate ideas though campaigns like pirate cycling and diaspora yatra. This brought mainstream attention, reach among the public and brought in many new members.

Akshay

@arkarjun you're now the first permanent member.
I've created the voting members subgroup with initial members and you. New permanent members should be added to this group too.

You may create a permanent members subgroup too, I guess.

Pirate Praveen

Now we have 50% women Initial Members who can make decisions on behalf of Indian Pirates. We should continue our efforts to involve more women. Now we cannot accept any more Initial Members. Anyone can become an Associate Member and after 6 months of promoting our ideas through campaigns, events and other creative means, can become permanent members.

Akshay

@nandajavarma , you're an initial member now. Welcome! You can now vote other members in.

ark Arjun

I ark Arjun would like to be a permanent member of India Pirates.
Why I think I am eligible?
I was been an initial member since the start of the pirate movement. I have designed previous logo of "pirate movement India" and been part of many activities of indian pirates including the recent diaspora yatra. The logo, cartoon, flayer, stickers was designed by me, also organised and spoke many events in 2 districts.

Pirate Praveen

@soorajkenoth , @suneesh , @balasankarchelamat , @arkarjun , @shirish , @rajudvindane (and myself), our initial membership has expired. Initial members who joined after us will approve permanent membership requests now. We can apply for permanent membership now.

Pirate Praveen

@jacksonisaac you are an initial member now! welcome!

Akshay

Where as puting a gun on your head and commanding you to help your neighbor is wrong.

There's no gun! It's a democracy.
A democracy is a government of the people, by the people, for the people. It's built by people who agree that their group has become so large (like India), that they need to have people dedicated to be looking after the internal affairs (representatives), rather than being directly involved (like in ancient Greece).

In such a democracy, there's no gun. But then there are democratic processes, which you've agreed with, which're used to enforce the decision of the collective upon you.

And as far as I see, democracy allows the maximum freedom to dissenters. In the sense, if someone doesn't want to live by the rules of the government, they're free to live their life alone, without any interaction with people who agree to the democratic process.

When you earn money, you're agreeing to the democratic process. Because money is introduced by the Government. Now that you've agreed to the democratic process, it's only rational that you're expected to follow democratic decisions.

--

Now, not all decisions are democratic. That is why Indian Pirates exist. We make sure democracy is followed in its right spirit. In another sense, we redefine what democracy means to people.

It must be a necessary consequence of our FOSS backgrounds that we believe it is better for everyone if people cooperate without expecting rewards.
I don’t think people are doing things without expecting rewards. Money is not the only reward.

Read this as proportional rewards. People are cooperating expecting the safety of a democray and some reward, but not necessarily proportional. So when you work hard you can earn a lot of money, but you'll have to pay a lot of tax, and also you'll be guaranteed the security of your money. There are tradeoffs. It's something you have to live with.

I didn't read Virtue of Selfishness. But does it suggest a way of life which wouldn't involve a government? How do you live without a government? And when there's a government, what kind of government should it be, if it's not democratic? @jemshidkk I assume you aren't a caveman because you are accessing Internet. But unless you dug your own well, even the water you're drinking has been brought to you by cooperation.

You're free to dissent and live alone. But I don't find a way how you can, or why you should.

Jemshid KK

@akshay
//you are saying taxing the people who put “more effort” in order to help people who put “less effort” is wrong.//
There is nothing wrong in somebody helping poor by his choice. Where as puting a gun on your head and commanding you to help your neighbor is wrong.
When I find that the tax I pay is being used to support ideas which I do not agree with, do I have freedom to stay away from paying tax?

//It must be a necessary consequence of our FOSS backgrounds that we believe it is better for everyone if people cooperate without expecting rewards.//
I don't think people are doing things without expecting rewards. Money is not the only reward.

//You’re right, in today’s world where there’s no consensus for cooperation, where people are competing with each other, working harder and being selfish is the natural way of doing things.//
Cooperation has to be a thing of choice, not a command.
And I would say we should never denounce hard work or work. We live our life consuming the output of work.
Now coming to the selfishness part, I would say, we should be selfish and selfishness (concern with one's own interests) is the way to go.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Virtue_of_Selfishness

//And we have a feeling that it’d be.//
Is it a feeling or a rational conclusion?

//I guess there are two ways of looking at life on Earth.
1. Ubuntu - an altruistic philsophy.
2. Everything opposite to number 1. A competitive world where every tit must have a tat. A selfish philosophy.//

Here is a better selfish philosophy
"I swear by my life and my love of it, that I will never live for the sake of another man, nor ask another man to live for mine." John Galt.

Jemshid KK

@vik
// //When I produce something, it is mine and it is my right to decide what I should do with it. //
I guess this is where you and I would fundamentally disagree :) //

Precisely

//There should be dissenting voices and you are correct to make your feelings about the constitution clear//

My intention is not to put feelings here.

Jemshid KK

@praveen
//your logic is built up on certain assumptions like everyone has an equal opportunity, which is not a reality. //

I am not saying that everyone has equal opportunity. Infact as long I can not have an objective measure of opportunity, I can not attempt a comparison.

//Your free markets need rational actors, which is not the case either. //

Are you a rational actor?

Jemshid KK

@praveenarimbrathod
//when you say you produced it yourself, you forgot the knowledge that was produced by generations, even the language you used to learn is not yours, the hard work of people who were exploited as slaves, untouchables, using guns or swords. //

Who own the knowledge produced by generations?
@vik
It is not just guns that produced slaves. Being a slave is an attitude too. When we loose confidence to produce things we need, we beg a master (state) to feed us. When I assume that I am not capable of producing things, rather I should wait for my luck to get employed by a master, a slave is born.

An employement is not a courtesy of the employer. It is a trade with mutual respect. The employee sells his skils and time and the employer pays for it.

//You logic is totally without a historic context as if you are creating things from vacuum with your personal magic.//

It is not history, it's philosophy that governs my logic.

//Some people worship God, some worship markets. //

If you find it is not reason and logic but worship is governing my arguments, what is the point in having a discussion here?
I am looking for conversation based on logic and reason.

// I also wants competition and hard work to be rewarded, but not when a large number of people are systematically oppressed. //

When you limit / arrest competitiveness and and hardwork by others, you are oppressing otheres and their well being and freedom and that is what precisely a dictatoship does. The solution to systematic oppression is not another way of systematic oppression.

Pirate Praveen

@jemshidkk when you say you produced it yourself, you forgot the knowledge that was produced by generations, even the language you used to learn is not yours, the hard work of people who were exploited as slaves, untouchables, using guns or swords. You logic is totally without a historic context as if you are creating things from vacuum with your personal magic. Some people worship God, some worship markets. I also wants competition and hard work to be rewarded, but not when a large number of people are systematically oppressed.

Pirate Praveen

@jemshidkk your logic is built up on certain assumptions like everyone has an equal opportunity, which is not a reality. Your free markets need rational actors, which is not the case either. Anyway we can still work together on issues of mutual interest. This discussion group is open to all and dissent is valuable to us.

Pirate Vik

//When I produce something, it is mine and it is my right to decide what I should do with it. //

I guess this is where you and I would fundamentally disagree :)

//Nobody has right to take it away from me with a gun.//

Now this, we can agree on.

//I am OK with participating in the discussion without being a member of Indian Pirates. If you people are also OK about, I will be lisetning to your discussions and contributing to it once in a while.//

Absolutely. There should be dissenting voices and you are correct to make your feelings about the constitution clear, others may agree with you.

Jemshid KK

@praveenarimbrathod
//do you think UK, Norway, Canada are fascist?//

I can not comment much about this question. I don't know about their constitution and justice system.
But I know something. When I produce something, it is mine and it is my right to decide what I should do with it. Nobody has right to take it away from me with a gun. When gun (physical force) becomes the arbitrator, there is no scope for further dialogue.
When I produce something and I don't want to reveal it to the world, and If the government is curious about it, isn't it a violation of privacy?

//We are proposing policies and seeking support from people. It is called politics. Or do you think we should not propose any policies at all?//
My point is that even when we get a majority, we should not use physical force to dictate the life and decisions of any woman/man on earth. If anybody is violating rights of somebody else with a gun, gun is the way to go.

//Anyone can get voting rights if they can convinse at least two existing voting members about their commitments to these values.//
//You have to publicly state your acceptance of the constitution//
//If you disagree with any of the points in the constitution, we can discuss it here as well.//

I do not accept the constitution in the current form. I started this discussion stating my dissent to Article 1, Section 3. And sofar to my understanding, I am taking this discussion forward based on logic and reason.
I am OK with participating in the discussion without being a member of Indian Pirates. If you people are also OK about, I will be lisetning to your discussions and contributing to it once in a while.

Pirate Vik

@jemshidkk I disagree that the brick that you produce with your effort belongs to you. You we're given the knowledge to make that brick by someone else. You excavated the raw materials from somewhere too.

Secondly, when I am talking about finite employment, I think I am correct. Consider western free markets such as the UK. Here we used to follow the model of full employment and job creation by the state - so everybody could have a job.

Then throughout the Thatcher years we we're pushed along the road of the free market - which in the end reduced jobs, increased unemployment and we have had a mismatch between people and jobs ever since. This is the so called 'free society' where anyone can start a business and make themselves a millionaire - it's all depicted there in the American dream - unfortunately turns out it's actually a nightmare.

I understand very clearly who pays for healthcare and other state provision. I do! I pay huge sums of tax each year because I earn sufficient amounts of money.

I also understand that by earning that money and keeping it in my pocket - I deprive someone else of the possibility of having that money, because money is also finite. I understand that by having my job or business, I also deprive another person of occupying that spot, because I am already sitting in it.

The lazy man story seems to me an extension of the divide and rule approach of imperialists - and it works so, so well. We can easily feel so much more important that that "lazy person who doesn't work hard enough" without understanding anything about that persons life / ability / opportunity.

So very convenient.

Akshay

@jemshidkk , if I understand you right, you are saying taxing the people who put "more effort" in order to help people who put "less effort" is wrong.

I guess there are two ways of looking at life on Earth.
1. Ubuntu - an altruistic philsophy.
2. Everything opposite to number 1. A competitive world where every tit must have a tat. A selfish philosophy.

It must be a necessary consequence of our FOSS backgrounds that we believe it is better for everyone if people cooperate without expecting rewards.

You're right, in today's world where there's no consensus for cooperation, where people are competing with each other, working harder and being selfish is the natural way of doing things.

But the philsophy of Indian Pirates (or what I wish is its philosophy) is to create a new world order in which cooperation is the default way of doing things, and selfishness is exception.

Now there's no proof this works. Maybe in such a world order everyone will become lazy and it may collapse. But if it turns out that it doesn't collapse, that people get motivated to work for each other when they don't have the pressure of working for survival, that as a whole human civilization will be able to achieve more progress in such a kind of world, then it would be great. And we have a feeling that it'd be.

Jemshid KK

@vik
//Your talking about basic facilities and linking the right to those basic facilities with the effort you have made. Using your analogy above, do you have the right to use the bricks that your more ‘lazy’ neighbour could have used had he got there first? Maybe he wasn’t as lucky to be educated in the same way as you?//

A brick is not a natural resource. It needs to be produced by somebody. When I produce it, it is mine and it is my right to decide what I should do with it.
If you are talking about limited natural resources, it belongs to the whole world. Every human being on the earth has a share of ownership on it.
Coming to the the brick again, a brick is wealth and wealth is not a limited thing on earth, but is being produced with effort. There is nothing I have to do with the brick my neigbor got. If I need a brick I will make a brick. Or may be better in modern times, I will make some wheat and trade it with my neighbor for bricks.

//For me, the measure of a civilisation is how well do we care for each other? How do we lift up the poorest and most vulnerable in our society.//

If this is the measure of civilization for you and you desire to be civilized, then you should work towards it. But when you insist your measure of civilization on somebody else with a gun, it is a totally different thing. It is fascism or dictatorship.

//I feel lucky to live in a country where we have:
A National Health Service - where I get free access to Doctors and Hospital treatment

If I lose my job I get Unemployment Benefit so I can meet my basic needs. I get Housing Benefit so that I can pay my rent.

If I am sick, I get statutory sick pay.

If a become disabled I get disability benefits.//

Did you ever think Who pays for health care?
If you are lazy to produce wheat for you to eat, who is toiling to produce wheat for you?
Doesn't it look like you desire for a master - slave society where government is the master and you are a salve.

//Politicians often use the language of ‘lazy’ to gain support from those who do not want to pay tax in order to look after other members in society, but they never really have an answer to the fact that employment is finite and the number of opportunities are less than the number of people. //

Your argument is based on the premise that employemnt is finite. Which is grossly wrong.
Yes employment is finite in a socialist / communist regime, where every business is owned by government and you are not free to start your own business or work.
In a free society, the question isn't who is going to let me; it's who is going to stop me.

//Regardless of how industrious a person is, there is a huge amount of luck involved in getting enough money to get by.//

“I don’t subscribe to luck or chance, Miss Steele. The harder I work the more luck I seem to have." !!
-Christian Grey, Fifty Shades of Grey !

Buy the way if you need a better reply for your last sentence, I can explain further.

Pirate Praveen

@jemshidkk do you think UK, Norway, Canada are fascist?

We are proposing policies and seeking support from people. It is called politics. Or do you think we should not propose any policies at all?

Without mass support these policies are not going to be implemented and these are not holy statements that won't be changed at all. We are open to discussions and we'll make changes if we are convinsed. These principles will continue to be revised and refined as we engage with wider audience. We are also glad to have this debate here. At this point the items listed are considered basic. It may change in future. We make changes to these documents based on consensus of the voting members. Anyone can get voting rights if they can convinse at least two existing voting members about their commitments to these values. All decisions are made in open discussions that anyone can see. Indeed we might have short comings like anything new. We are using the power of internet to connect people and build a non hierarchical collective. Every member could participate in the policy making process. Indeed that leaves out people who don't have internet, we need to find a way to address that.

Pirate Vik

@jemshidkk Your talking about basic facilities and linking the right to those basic facilities with the effort you have made. Using your analogy above, do you have the right to use the bricks that your more 'lazy' neighbour could have used had he got there first? Maybe he wasn't as lucky to be educated in the same way as you?

For me, the measure of a civilisation is how well do we care for each other? How do we lift up the poorest and most vulnerable in our society.

I feel lucky to live in a country where we have:
A National Health Service - where I get free access to Doctors and Hospital treatment

If I lose my job I get Unemployment Benefit so I can meet my basic needs. I get Housing Benefit so that I can pay my rent.

If I am sick, I get statutory sick pay.

If a become disabled I get disability benefits.

Politicians often use the language of 'lazy' to gain support from those who do not want to pay tax in order to look after other members in society, but they never really have an answer to the fact that employment is finite and the number of opportunities are less than the number of people. Regardless of how industrious a person is, there is a huge amount of luck involved in getting enough money to get by.

Jemshid KK

When a group of people together (collective) decide to sacrifices / spend their money / resources for somebody or for some purpose, there is nothing wrong in it. But when the group insist with gun (physical force) on others who doesn't agree with their idea to do the same thing, we call it fascism. Hitler was elected democratically.

//we, as a collective believe// : Does it sound like religion or communism? What would be the difference between belief and conviction? Can there be a belief based on reason and logic?

//basic facilities// : Who will decide my facilities and your basic facilities?

//If we can convinse enough people this is the right thing to do, we will use democratic means to achieve them// :
If we can convince enough people about this belief, let the convinced people do it according to their belief.
The second part of the sentence, "we will use democratic means to achieve it" is scary. An idea which has a majority by counting number of people supporting it, being imposed on somebody else by physical force is not democracy. It is mobocracy, fascism or dictatorship.

"Many countries in Europe already do this.":
Have no respect for the authority of others, for there are always contrary authorities to be found.! - Bertrand Russel!!

PS: @praveen , I like this conversation and I think it is valuable.

Pirate Praveen

@jemshidkk we, as a collective believe people getting basic facilities should not be on the basis of their dad's merit. If we can convinse enough people this is the right thing to do, we will use democratic means to achieve them. Many countries in Europe already do this.

Jemshid KK

"do you believe luck should be at the center of deciding if people have basic facilities?"
Who will decide my basic facilities, my neighbors basic facilities and your basic facilities.

"Do people get a choice if their parents are rich or poor?"
No

"Do you think a rich kid getting lots of money from his father is his merit and hard work?"
It is not kid's merit, it is his fathers merit.

Pirate Praveen

@jemshidkk do you believe luck should be at the center of deciding if people have basic facilities? Do people get a choice if their parents are rich or poor? Do you think rich and poor gets equal opportunities? Do you think a rich kid getting lots of money from his father is his merit and hard work?

Nandaja Varma

I, Nandaja Varma, have read and understood the constitution of Pirate party. I agree to it and would like to be an initial member.

Jemshid KK

Article 1: Basic Principles
Section 3: Every one has a right to food, housing, education, healthcare and privacy

The food we eat these days in general, the house we live and health care are not natural resources. We need to put an effort and cultivate our food or construct our house.

When I build a house for me, do my lazy neighbor has a right on my house?

If I am not willing open my house to the lazy neighbor, the government is going to use physical force to take the output of my effort and distribute it to the lazy neighbor. (Taxation). Which is a violation of Article 1, Section 6.

I find something not right here.

Vidyut

Thank you.

Jackson Isaac

I, Jackson Isaac, have read and I agree to the constitution of the Pirate Movement.
I believe everyone should have the freedom of knowledge and expression.
I would like to join this Pirate Ship and spread word about freedom to knowledge with all of you.

Pirate Praveen

@vidyut you are an initial member now! Welcome!

Pirate Praveen

@jemshidkk you have to state your acceptance of the constitution here to be considered as an initial member.

Pirate Praveen

@truptirajeshkini you are an initial member now. Welcome! She is our first women initial member.

Vidyut

I agree to the constitution.

Membership request.

Trupti Rajesh Kini

I liked the attitude in this phrase "We should no longer accept what we supposedly cannot change. Instead, we need to change what we cannot accept". I am completely opposed to restrictions and love to share knowledge. The term "Pirate" is apt for this movement. I would like to be part of this movement as an initial member and will change the world in my way.

Pirate Praveen

@fayadfami I have updated the description here.

Fayad Fami

@praveenarimbrathod Thanks for adding. I assumed both to be the same. Couldn't find about Initial member in constitution, so got confused. Maybe its good to have a short description for both at the top of this thread.

Edit: Found it under constitution. Sorry for the confusion. Still it would be good to have the same at the top. Just a humble thought.