COllaborative DEcision MAking (codema.in)

Organization Structure

Pirate Praveen PublicSeen by 784

I propose we create a constitution for ourselves and define membership and responsibilities.

Also we can use Swathanthra Malayalam Computing (http://smc.org.in) as a legal custodian of our assets similar to how SPI handles assets and financial transactions for debian project.

Update (09/02/2017): We need to revisit this thread now and finish this task of defining a structure.

  1. Each sub team like poddery.com maintainers or git.fosscommunity.in should be able to take technical decisions independently. We can have them like special teams in debian (FTP masters, release team etc).
  2. We can create email accounts for official members
  3. Any time contribution to Free Software should be enough to get a membership (be it coding, design, support, publicity etc)
  4. Their contribution should be vouched by existing members (we can have initial members from this loomio group/riot group/mailing list).
  5. This structure can help us make official statements with everyone given a fair opportunity to comment.
  6. Ownership of assets like domains could be given to legal entities like SMC. Just like debian, we can have multiple organizations as trusted organizations to keep assets. We can ask other groups like DFF, SFLC, DAKF etc

Basically we need ensure we can sustain these services even if the current maintainers become inactive (I want to make myself redundant).

Further reading:

  1. https://wiki.debian.org/Teams/DPL/TrustedOrganizationCriteria has criteria debian uses to select trusted organizations.

  2. https://wiki.debian.org/Teams/Auditor/Organizations has list of organizations trusted by debian.

  3. https://www.debian.org/devel/constitution#item-9 is the section about trusted organizations.

Update (10/02/2017):

Preamble:

  1. Free Software Community of India is a collective of Free Software (sometimes also called as Open Source Software) users, advocates and developers.
  2. We maintain communication and collaboration infrastructure for everyone that respects their freedom and privacy.
  3. We depend on donations and community manpower to run the infrastructure.
  4. We maintain a list of Free Software communities and offer sub domains of fsug.in or fosscommunity.in
  5. We mentor Free Software enthusiasts to become Free Software contributors.
  6. We provide GNU/Linux installation and configuration support via online messaging groups.

Make SMC our legal home

proposal by Pirate Praveen Closed Wed 2 Oct 2013 11:47AM

Outcome
by Pirate Praveen

We are using SMC for our legal backing.

Yes - We can assign legal ownership of our assets (domians, servers etc) and authorize accepting money on our behalf (we did this already for savepoddery.com).

No - I don't agree to this proposal.

Results

Pirate Praveen
Agree

This will ensure our assets will be maintained properly and we can continue building free communication infrastructures.

Pavithran S
Agree

yes it would be easy to accept money .

Sooraj Kenoth
Block

I don't think it as good idea, as SMC is entirely different entity with different objectives.

Sooraj Kenoth
Abstain

I don't think it as good idea, as SMC is entirely different entity with different objectives.

Manu Krishnan T V
Abstain

SMC's major area of work is limited to a geographic location. But this can be much wider.

Anish Sheela
Agree

Its a pain to start and maintain a community. Better to keep backing from SMC. I think keeping separate logical accounts would be great.

Anish Sheela
Agree

Its a pain to start and maintain a legal entity. Better to keep backing from SMC. I think keeping separate logical accounts would be great.

stultus
Agree

SMC is already a registered society. so with a legal backing from smc ( handling money , tax , etc) will be definitely helpful. later when fosscommunity.in grow out of the box , we can always create a new legal structure.

Balasankar C
Agree

I think it is ok to merge with SMC if and only if they are ok with it. We should never become a burden to SMC. We can always merge and fork na? So let's make SMC our legal home.

Akhil Krishnan S
Disagree

Quoting sooraj's opinion
"SMC is entirely different entity with different objectives."

Pirate Praveen

@manukrishnantv we just need someone to handle legal side, so geography is not an issue, I think.

Manu Krishnan T V

It was just my opinion. Lets see what others think.

Pirate Praveen

@balasankarchelamat providing logistical support to Free Software communities is one of the core objectives of SMC (society).

Sooraj Kenoth

@akhilkrishnans I have a small correction. That statement was a mistake from me. I was not an active participant in fosscommunity.in. When saw the discussion, I thought it is about pirate movement. Personally I don't like to connect pirate movement with SMC. So I blocked it. When I realized the mistake I corrected it. I apologise for the mistake I made.

Balasankar C

To make things transparent, shouldn't the SMC members (who are not member of FCI) have a word on the issue?? Why don't we make it like this - FCI is requesting SMC to be its legal supporter, SMC places the discussion in front of its members, SMC members decide what to do. If they are fine, lets do it.

I don't think, the stuff involving another organization should be discussed in a platform like this. SMC must be informed formally about this request (via mail so that everyone knows) and let them respond.

Anish Sheela

@balasankarchelamat Yes. You are right. That need to be second step. After this discussion closes, we can discuss in SMC mailing list and can give a letter to SMC from us describing the situation.

This voting is solely for consent from FCI members regarding this.

Once they accept it, then only this become possible. If not, we propose alternatives. That's my thought on this.

Balasankar C

I believe SMC's General Assembly agreed to this request.

Pirate Praveen

We need to revisit this thread now and finish this task of defining a structure.

  1. Each sub team like poddery.com maintainers or git.fosscommunity.in should be able to take technical decisions independently. We can have them like special teams in debian (FTP masters, release team etc).
  2. We can create email accounts for official members
  3. Any time contribution to Free Software should be enough to get a membership (be it coding, design, support, publicity etc)
  4. Their contribution should be vouched by existing members (we can have initial members from this loomio group/riot group/mailing list).
  5. This structure can help us make official statements with everyone given a fair opportunity to comment.
  6. Ownership of assets like domains could be given to legal entities like SMC. Just like debian, we can have multiple organizations as trusted organizations to keep assets. We can ask other groups like DFF, SFLC, DAKF etc

Basically we need ensure we can sustain these services even if the current maintainers become inactive (I want to make myself redundant).

Pirate Praveen

Sharing the discussion points in #fci:matrix.org

Vikram Vincent

Pirate Praveen: read the thread on FCI assets. I don't have an opinion on it since I was involved with FCI years ago.

Pirate Praveen

Vikram Vincent: ok, we are trying to reactivate the wiki/website and make it more sustainable by defining/documenting teams, processes etc

Vikram Vincent

Fsmk being a legal entity handles issues of assets thru its committee.

This was something we designed from the early stages itself

Not sure why you selected smc over other orgs but I assume it is because a lot of you are from smc, right?
B

Another way would be to create FCI into a legal entity but I don't know if it is too late for that

Pirate Praveen

Vikram Vincent: yes, most of us knew smc well enough to ask at that time

Vikram Vincent: I prefer the way debian does it


there is one community without legal entity and multiple trusted organizations for legal requirement, owning assets etc

Vikram Vincent

Pirate Praveen: how would u implement such a distributed plan? Is there some legal text I can read to understand?

Pirate Praveen

debian has many legal trusted organizations like SPI in US, debian.ch in switzerland, debian Japan etc

Vikram Vincent

Right. In a region there is one trusted org. But FCI is distributed across India and smc is located in one place

So I don't see how your idea is implemented..

Pirate Praveen

Vikram Vincent: see https://wiki.debian.org/Teams/DPL/TrustedOrganizationCriteria

Teams/DPL/TrustedOrganizationCriteria - Debian Wiki
Wiki Login FrontPage RecentChanges FindPage HelpContents TrustedOrga...ionCriteria Search: Wiki / Login Comments Info Attachments More Actions: Raw Text

Vikram Vincent: smc was just the first, we can always add more

Vikram Vincent

I read that. For example, in US, Debian as one trusted org and not several, right?


How would u handle conflicts among among multiple trusted orgs?

Pirate Praveen

Vikram Vincent: what kind of conflicts? its FCI -> trusted org interactions, we only have to worry about interaction with that organization and FCI
12:16
for example if we want to add FSMK as a trusted organization, somene in FCI can propose it and if its accepted, we can ask FSMK about their position


if there is a conflict between FSMK and SMC for example, that does not affect us

Vikram Vincent

So each trusted org handles a different aspect, I assume

Cannot be the same asset

Pirate Praveen

Vikram Vincent: yes
S
Vikram Vincent
12:18
Ah ok

Pirate Praveen

discussion with @jayaura on matrix/riot.

Aurabindo

Pirate Praveen: if FSMK and SMC are trusted orgs and they have a conflict, shouldnt FCI intervene and help resolve that ? How can it not affect FCI?
B

(assuming that FCI is legal and SMC FSMK are added as TOs)

Pirate Praveen

Aurabindo: the need for trusted organizations arise because we/FCI is not a legal entity

Aurabindo

well I didnt put it correctly. I know FCI is not legal at the moment. I was just asking the question in the hypothetical situation where FCI has become legal

Pirate Praveen

Aurabindo: having friends in both organizations, we can try an mediate in a conflict, but that should not affect us. Each of them will be holding a different asset.

Aurabindo: then we don't need any TO, we can handle our own assets

Aurabindo

Right, if the conflicts are over different assets, it should legally 'affect' FCI

But is there absolutely no chance of having such a conflict on assets that may be common? For instance, lets say an individual donates some infrastructure to FCI which both TO 'A' and 'B' would love to have. If the donor has not specifically mentioned whom the resource should be donated, then there could be an issue that FCI need to deal with, isnt it ?

or such cases are out of scope ?

Pirate Praveen

Aurabindo: there are bigger conflicts, even between countries? How do people solve it? People try to talk, have a mediator etc. This is a pure hypothetical situation, we are all people, we can think about a response when there is a conflict

Aurabindo: A or B don't have a say in decision making, FCI decides or the donor decides

FCI can tell the donor to give it to either A or B

Aurabindo

Right. So that the rule put forward by FCI. I think such cases needs to be well documented

if we are moving ahead with this idea

Pirate Praveen

Aurabindo: yes, we can use the debian't criteria as a starting point

Aurabindo

And for TO's to be interested in joining FCI, there needs to some perks they have with the membership

First one I can think of, is managing the legal aspects

Pirate Praveen

Aurabindo: no, the TO don't join FCI

Aurabindo

taxes etc ( if they apply)

I see

Pirate Praveen

both FCI and TO will see if the goals are aligned

Aurabindo

Okay

Pirate Praveen

in this case SMC or FSMK will see if supporting FCI helps Free Software, which is a goal of both those orgs

FCI will check the trackrecord of SMC and FSMK before approaching them and they will in turn check the track record of FCI

it helps when there are common members
B

many members are common between SMC and FCI so they can vouch for each other organizations

12:48
now if some members of FSMK or DFF or DAKF becomes a part of FCI, they can propose/vouch

@balasankarc

I know I am talking in future tenst, but still: My personal opinion for FCI is to not go legal. I love FCI to be always a community and not an "organization".
B
Pirate Praveen

@balasankarc: that is my preference too

there will be many compulsions when going legal, when there are already many legal entities that share the same goal of promoting Free Software, we don't need yet another one wanting to do the same

that why I like the way debian did it
B

its not just just debian many other projects gets affiliated with SPI or SFLC

Aurabindo

Pirate Praveen: I was not clear regarding the proposed relationship b/w FCI and SMC. Reading the debian constitution now

Pirate Praveen

https://sfconservancy.org/projects/current/

Current Projects - Software Freedom Conservancy
The Software Freedom Conservancy provides a non-profit home and services to Free, Libre and Open Source Software (FLOSS) projects.

Prasanth Sugathan: do SFLC.in offer a simialr service for communities in India?

Aurabindo

Pirate Praveen: @balasankarc Has there been any discussions on the pros and cons of going official ?

Pirate Praveen

http://www.spi-inc.org/projects/
projects
SPI / projects Home Contact Corporate Donations Meetings Membership Projects SPI Associated Projects We are proud to be able to list the following 46 free and open source projects as being associated with SPI.

12:57
Aurabindo: https://codema.in/d/1Z3oWqR7/proposal/9vBfM8VT
Loomio - Loomio

Pirate Praveen

Discussion with Arun M (fci@conference.diasp.in)

[11:44:42  IST] ‎arunm‎: Hi Praveen real problem is not organisation but we lack people doing real work
‎[11:44:49  IST] ‎arunm‎: Discuss politics
‎[11:45:06  IST] ‎arunm‎: Create next generation actisits
‎[11:54:05  IST] ‎praveen‎: arunm, I agree we need people who are motivated by politics, above thread is just an attempt to document the existing community, to sustain services like poddery.com and git.fosscommunity.in
‎[11:55:57  IST] ‎praveen‎: documenting processes helps new people to understand how how community works
‎[11:56:08  IST] ‎praveen‎: it is required to sustain a community
‎[11:57:27  IST] ‎praveen‎: we want a new member to know they can question the "seniors" and don't have to just follow
‎[11:58:24  IST] ‎praveen‎: this is mostly relevant for community ownership of infrastructure like the diaspora pod we run
‎[11:58:58  IST] ‎praveen‎: arunm, it is not a substitute for building activists
――――――――――――――――――――
‎[12:04:54  IST] ‎arunm‎: Praveen, I don't know. We need community it infrastructure like diaspora but the challenge is not one of Debian but that of autistici
‎[12:05:12  IST] ‎arunm‎: Debian model is not the best to me
‎[12:05:56  IST] ‎arunm‎: For debian community infrastructure is something to support its core community function of developing a free distro
‎[12:06:47  IST] ‎arunm‎: Here objective is to build shared it infrastructure for members use like email, data storage, messaging etc
‎[12:07:24  IST] ‎praveen‎: I'm looking at debian as "how a community work together"
‎[12:08:15  IST] ‎praveen‎: while autistici structure is good if we look at the output, but how do one join autistici?
‎[12:08:59  IST] ‎arunm‎: It may not work if they adopt debian model
‎[12:09:13  IST] ‎praveen‎: I'm more interrsted in growing the number of people who steps up to do the work
‎[12:09:39  IST] ‎praveen‎: hense looking at the debian structure
‎[12:09:48  IST] ‎arunm‎: Only way is work with them talk to them
‎[12:10:05  IST] ‎arunm‎: Discuss politics
‎[12:10:24  IST] ‎praveen‎: autistici/riseup is a closed group, though really committed and passionate people
‎[12:11:08  IST] ‎arunm‎: The spirit of rebellion and comradeship  
‎[12:13:16  IST] ‎praveen‎: but that usually ends up as small number of people in the front and large number following
‎[12:14:14  IST] ‎praveen‎: which I don't see as suatainable, as many times the people at the front get burned out or have to move out, the community dies with it

Pirate Bady

i'd like to question the necessity of having a constitution. doesn't it make things look more complicated than simply allowing people to associate freely? also one of the main reasons for not registering FCI as a legal entity is to avoid the complications that come with it, right? so my suggestion is to keep things simple by providing general guidelines instead of forming a constitution.

on the other hand it's fine if there are any solid reasons for creating a constitution. what all are the advantages of having a constitution (assuming that a constitution is no more valid than a set of guidelines when the organization isn't a registered one)?

Fayad Fami

I think it is a fact fci needs better organization. Constitution alone may not be enough for that. We will need to receive financial support, advices and backing in situations that needs backing.

As far as I understand we have members who've been part of smc and people who still work with smc. So the benefits overweights anything else. Besides organizations like smc are designed to support movements.

But only if more people from smc will step up and comment about this.

The measures outlined to organize fci will help to make it more official. Things will be streamlined, and new people will understand its worthiness and the need to contribute. Continue to have people from everywhere plus under one group with some structure.

Pirate Praveen

I think it is a fact fci needs better organization. Constitution alone may not be enough for that. We will need to receive financial support, advices and backing in situations that needs backing.

Like I said above, constitution alone is not sufficient, but it is necessary to sustain the community. It is more of a documentation, a declaration of intent and purpose. We can associate with many existing registered organizations that share our values and goals to take care of financial and legal needs. It is a common practice for many Free Software communities to isolate legal structure from community decision making. Software in the Public Interest, Software Freedom Conservancy, our own SMC, all have a goal of supporting the Free Software communities in their goals and many projects use these services. If we are unable to get that support from existing organizations, we can think about creating our own.

But only if more people from smc will step up and comment about this.

SMC has already agreed to support us. https://codema.in/d/1Z3oWqR7/comment/56345 I reopened this thread to complete writing a constitution that details our goals and a membership process so we become sustainable.

Pirate Praveen

I have added a preamble section in this thread's description. Please comment.

Deleted account

Regarding the second point of the preamble We maintain communication and collaboration infrastructure for everyone, like a diaspora pod with xmpp chat support at poddery.com and a gitlab instance at git.fosscommunity.in, I suggest that specific services not be mentioned in there. Preamble should be the introduction. Further sections should mention in detail what services are hosted, what domains are registered, and who are the present admins, etc.

Deleted account

Suggestion on point 2: How about changing from We maintain communication and collaboration infrastructure for everyone to We maintain communication and collaboration infrastructure for everyone that respects their freedom and privacy and depend on donations and community manpower to run the infrastructure

Pirate Praveen

Discussion with @jayaura about the name and stand about hardware.

Pirate Praveen: I think we need to clarify what is the official name of the organization: Is it FCI? If so, is that Free software Community of India or `Foss Community of India?

Or should we make it FLOSS ?

thats another usage I've come across in multiple places

And, why should we limit ourselves to just Software? Hardware deserves mention too!

@abhijith:matrix.org

Aurabindo: FLOSS seems too much

Aurabindo

@abhijith:matrix.org: I agree.

Pirate Praveen

Aurabindo: it was started as Foss community of India, but in descriptions I prefer to use Free Software

I don't like floss either


Aurabindo: propose a wording for hardware

we could change the name to Free Software Community of India

Aurabindo

Pirate Praveen: the question is whether hardware should be something thats important to this group. I am not aware of anyone who is into open hardware in here!

If there is enough interest, we can probably call it "Free Computing Community of India", to reflect that we also care about hardware

or something like that

or may be Free and Open Computing Community of India, FOCCI

In case we decide to include hardware, we need to come with a bang, like launching some hardware  project

we ofcourse, not commercially


I will be able to make a start with it. I have a DC Motor Driver in the work. Once tested, I'd like to release it open

Pirate Praveen

Aurabindo: well, even those hardware projects, we are only dealing with software, right?

Aurabindo: creating something like raspberry pi or fairphone or librem can be called a free hardware project

14:38
well, not rspberry pi, but olimex range of products have free hardware designs

and if we indeed start something later, we can always add it later too

Aurabindo

Pirate Praveen: open/free hardware need not necessarily be about making a generic full fledged computing system.  The DC motor driver i mentioned is something just like that. Presently I am not aware of any indian community thats interested in making hardware


and of course, associated free software for those hardware

I've come across one off projects like SnapVcc from electrnut.in etc

14:41
electronut.in

Change our name to Free Software Community of India

proposal by Pirate Praveen Closed Sun 12 Feb 2017 5:09AM

Outcome
by Pirate Praveen

Since it was blocked because of ambiguity over the word 'Free', we'll try Swatantra.

I think our activities are more aligned with the Free Software philosophy, rather than Open Source development model. I suggest we change our name to Free Software Community of India (FSCI). FOSS Community name was chosen initially to be neutral between the two camps, but I think we should take sides now.

Those who are new the debate, read https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point.html

Results

Pirate Praveen
Agree

yes, talking about freedom and ethics is more important

shirish
Agree

I completely agree as I find myself on the same side :)

Jackson Isaac
Block

I feel it can be easily confused with free as in freeware (that only allows to run the software for free) and not the 4 freedoms of open source software.

Nandakumar Edamana
Agree

Yes, Open Source is rather a business model. There is no space for a 'community' there.

Deleted account
Abstain

Option with multiple choices seems more logical for a decision to change name. This will help accommodate name suggestions from community members. This sounds more appropriate than to decide on or against just one particular name.

Pirate Praveen

@jacksonisaac would you agree if we change it to "Swatantra Software Community of India"? Swatantra translates to Freedom in many Indian languages and hence it won't confuse people.

Pirate Praveen

@jayaura we will try to get consensus, if that fails, we remain as FOSS Community of India. Lets just wait for everyone to respond. There is no multiple choice option in loomio currently.

Balasankar C

Yes. Open source is aligned more to the business concept of the idea. But, why alienate ourselves from that? And I totally agree with Stallman that open source misses the point of freedom. That's what "F" in FOSS is intended to solve. I am inclined towards FCI, but can live with FSCI.

Deleted account

As @jacksonisaac pointed out, newbies might consider 'Free' software as just 'available for free'. In most places where 'Free Software' is mentioned, it is occasionally followed by the tag 'Free as in Freedom'. Since the actual idea is Freedom with Software, why not just include the full word Freedom itself rather than just 'Free'. This is along the likes of SFLC. Eg., Software Freedom Community of India

Pirate Bady

Constitution is just a name that people understand, naming it guidelines would be okay too. It is something we show to new people. How do someone new to fosscommunity.in know who we are, what we do, why we are doing it, how can they become a part, do they get the same rights etc. Without a defined structure and process for accepting new members, growth will not be sustainable as a small group will only feel the ownership and when they become inactive, the groups dies too.

i agree with you. first i thought FCI is just a gateway to get connected with various Free Software Communities all over india. but since FCI is also providing many services on its own, i understand it's important to have a well-defined structure.

Pirate Bady

Any time contribution to Free Software should be enough to get a membership (be it coding, design, support, publicity etc)
Their contribution should be vouched by existing members (we can have initial members from this loomio group/riot group/mailing list).

should we take it that far? i mean why complicating the membership process, is there anything wrong with simply granting membership for anyone who requests it? (assuming that those who request membership will be naturally FOSS enthusiasts).

Change our name to Swatantra Software Community of India

proposal by Pirate Praveen Closed Sat 25 Feb 2017 7:27AM

Outcome
by Pirate Praveen

Swatantra is ambiguous in Telugu, it means more like self-owned or self-sustained. Mukt is suggested as a better option.

I think our activities are more aligned with the Free Software philosophy, rather than Open Source development model. I suggested we change our name to Free Software Community of India (FSCI). FOSS Community name was chosen initially to be neutral between the two camps, but I think we should take sides now.

But earlier proposal was blocked because of ambiguity of the word 'Free', hence changing it to Swatantra, which means Freedom in many Indian languages.

Those who are new the debate, read https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point.html

Results

Pirate Praveen
Agree

Swatantra is unambiguous about Freedom

Balasankar C
Agree

Yes. Swatantra feels right.

Murali
Agree

100% solidarity with the name change...

Anoop
Abstain

I'd rather support to change the name to FLOSS (Free/Libre and Open Source Software).