COllaborative DEcision MAking (codema.in)

Lobby the govt to keep NUUP access to Free Software users

Pirate Praveen Sat 10 Jan 2026 4:31PMPublicSeen by 83

I think we should lobby the govt to keep NUUP (https://wiki.fsci.in/NUUP *99# USSD interface to UPI) and extend it to all cities and providers or it might get silently dropped one day.

This is currently the best option for Free Software, when it works (the biggest drawback is its limited support - Airtel in some select cities only).

Even if LibreFin manages to finish the reverse engineering effort, like NewPipe breaking often when Youtube changing its API.

We can try to work with other organizations and communities like LibreFin, FOSS United and SFLC.in.

Badri SunderarajanSun 11 Jan 2026 6:47AM

I like this initiative in principle, although I am not sure what to do about it in practice. Similarly, I was unable to find ways to contact those in charge of NUUP (until recent discussion in group chats) or else I would have least complained privately. I would be happy to participate in whatever way I can.

Pirate PraveenSun 11 Jan 2026 9:37AM

I think we can start with filing an RTI request with DoT. Asking about,

  1. What is the current status on NUUP/*99# USSD interface to UPI?

  2. Is it officially supported way to interact with UPI service?

  3. Have you tested/confirmed it is working across all providers and in all cities?

  4. Provide a list of cities where this will work?

  5. Is there any plan to discontinue this service?

Depending on their official stand on this matter we might have to try different things. If it is officially supported, we have a stronger position to demand it.

Pirate PraveenMon 12 Jan 2026 9:18AM

@Nemo what do you think? Is it worth pursuing?

NemoMon 12 Jan 2026 10:44AM

DoT isn't very responsible for NUUP. It held one consultation back in 2012, but has been uninvolved since. Any RTI questions will be responded with a redirect to the Telco itself. See pg 61-69 here https://www.trai.gov.in/sites/default/files/rti/RTI_June_13072022.pdf for eg where someone filed an RTI against TRAI with similar questions.

The only data RBI seems to have is around payment-systems-indicators, where USSD Payments have gone from 18crore in Oct 2024 to 13 crore in Oct 2025 (against 27 Lakh Crore in UPI). NUUP runs as a service integrated against Telcos, so your best bet would be to send a mail to NPCI, and BSNL perhaps?

Life is TetrisSat 24 Jan 2026 3:27AM

How secure is USSD? They outlawed "pull" requests in UPI citing the fraud angle. They have a good argument for USSD too.

Pirate PraveenMon 6 Jul 2026 5:08AM

While looking at Apple and Google monopolies and possibility of filing complaint with CCI, I think we can use the same strategy against BHIM. We can file a complaint against NCPI for favoring only Airtel with *99# implementation. I think the responsibility of fixing other providers is with NPCI.

Pirate PraveenMon 6 Jul 2026 6:01AM

If we can make valid complaint to CCI, at minimum NPCI will have to provide an answer to CCI why they provide this only on Airtel in practice. Since we are not getting an answer from them, at least we can force them to provide an answer.

FbIN (VB)Mon 6 Jul 2026 6:11AM

Literally read through each comment here:

I think, we should again ask NPCI for an official position.

  • Is *99# still a supported UPI interface?

  • Which operators are expected to support it?

  • Is Airtel the only compliant operator?

  • Are operators required to implement it?

Based on their response we can publish the findings.

Then probably get FSCI, LibreFin and SFLC to sign a joint letter.

Finally, let us see what NPCI confirms about the list of operators who should support it. If they say all, good, but if they don't, then we have a much stronger basis for approaching regulators or, if appropriate, considering a competition complaint.

NPCI wise - Unless we get a bounce, then we should escalate again through RBI rather than NPCI. AFAIK, NPCI operates UPI, but it does so under RBI's oversight.

FbIN (VB)Mon 6 Jul 2026 6:42AM

I actually think there is a path before CCI, and it may be stronger legally.

The problem with going to CCI first is that CCI is not a discovery mechanism. They won't investigate simply because NPCI isn't replying to emails. We will still need to show either:

  • abuse of dominant position under the Competition Act, or

  • anti-competitive conduct.

At the moment, what we have is more like failure of accountability than evidence of anti-competitive conduct.

NPCI is an RBI-authorised payment system operator. If it is not responding to policy questions or its published support channels are ineffective, RBI is the supervisory authority under the Payment and Settlement Systems Act.

Rather than asking RBI to answer questions about NUUP, we should ask something like:

We have repeatedly attempted to obtain clarification from NPCI regarding the operational status and support commitments for the NUUP (*99#) service. Multiple community members have used the available support channels without obtaining a substantive response. Kindly advise:

  1. Which authority is responsible for policy decisions regarding NUUP?

  2. Does RBI expect NPCI to provide a mechanism for responding to public queries regarding payment systems operated under RBI authorisation?

  3. If not NPCI, which authority should be approached?


Basically we are reaching out for accountability, rather than asking questions, which I am sure RBI cannot ignore to come back to.

BTW, I just saw that NPCI has a complaint register page (https://www.npci.org.in/complaint-register). I am sure we must have already tried it, and if not, maybe we should try that out too.

FbIN (VB)Mon 6 Jul 2026 12:54PM

Also, I wrote a small letter (medium letter tbvh). Please point out what corrections, amendments we should make to this. This is very high level (maybe some missing info) letter.

Preserving NUUP (*99#) as an Open Interface to UPI

The Free Software Community of India (FSCI) has been discussing the future of the National Unified USSD Platform (NUUP), accessible via *99#, as it is currently one of the very few ways to access UPI without depending on proprietary mobile applications.

This discussion did not begin as an advocacy campaign. It began because several members noticed that the service was no longer working reliably and tried to understand why.

Over the past few months, members have tested *99# across different telecom operators, banks and locations. Although the exact point of failure varies, the overall pattern has been remarkably consistent. Airtel users are generally able to complete transactions, whereas users of other major operators such as Jio, Vi and BSNL encounter failures at one stage or another. The problem has been reproduced by multiple people using different devices and bank accounts.

We do not know why this happens.

It may be a technical issue, an operational issue, a contractual issue between NPCI and telecom operators, or something else entirely. At present there is no public information that explains the situation.

Before considering any formal action, members of the community tried to report the problem through the channels made available by NPCI.

Some contacted the published BHIM support email addresses. Others used the BHIM feedback form. In one case the support team replied, but appeared to treat the complaint as one relating to a third-party UPI application and seemed unaware that the *99# service itself existed. Other emails either went unanswered or were returned as undeliverable. Collectively, these attempts have not produced any meaningful explanation of the current status of NUUP or why it appears to work only on one telecom network.

The result is an accountability gap. We have a nationally deployed payment interface that behaves differently depending on the telecom operator being used, yet there is no obvious authority willing or able to explain why.

This matters for reasons that go beyond the Free Software community.

NUUP was introduced as a way of making digital payments available on basic mobile phones without requiring Internet access. Those benefits remain relevant today. It is useful for feature phone users, people in areas with unreliable connectivity, users of older devices, and anyone who wants a simple, low-bandwidth method of accessing UPI.

For Free Software users, it has become even more important. Modern UPI applications increasingly depend on proprietary mobile platforms and technologies that are difficult or impossible to support in independent implementations. While projects such as LibreFin are working to improve the situation, reverse engineering proprietary systems is always vulnerable to changes outside the developer's control. An officially supported interface such as *99# provides a far more stable foundation.

We are not asking that NUUP be preserved simply because it is old or because it is useful to a small technical community. We are asking for clarity.

If NUUP remains an officially supported interface to UPI, users should be able to expect broadly consistent access regardless of which participating telecom operator they use. If this is not currently the case, it would be helpful to know why and what, if anything, is being done to address it.

If there has been a decision to withdraw or discontinue the service, that decision should be communicated publicly rather than allowing the service to fail gradually without explanation.

At present we are left with an unusual situation. The service appears to function reliably only on Airtel, repeated attempts to obtain clarification from NPCI through its published support channels have been unsuccessful, and there is no publicly available explanation of whether this is expected behaviour or evidence of a wider problem.

The first step is simply to establish the facts. Who is responsible for NUUP today? Is it still an officially supported interface to UPI? Are all participating telecom operators expected to support it? If not, why not?

Once those questions have been answered, it will be much easier to have an informed discussion about the future of the service.

Finally, I believe we should not be going only to CCI, or directly only to CCI. We need to reach to multiple ones, starting with RBI, including to SFLC for an intake.

Load More