COllaborative DEcision MAking (codema.in)

Proposal to welcome the recent decision by Indian Government that cancelled the 'Intermediary status' of Twitter in India.

Jigarkamble Wed 16 Jun 2021 2:29PMPublicSeen by 40

Failing to abide by the social media IT rules proposed by the present governance, Twitter have come to the forefront of criticism. The deadline date for compliance of the IT rules was on 26th May. Since then Twitter has failed to follow the rules and still has been upto their propagandistic behaviour of spreading fake news all across the Indian political sphere. Even after recurrent warnings and final notices from the government, the adamant social media giant had failed to employ an employee for the succinct functioning of the grievance redressal system as proposed by the Indian government.

The cancellation of the 'Intermediary status' of Twitter downgrades its 'platform' tag to 'publisher' tag thus enabling them to be legally responsible for posts posted in their outlet that violate the Indian laws.

Pirate VikWed 16 Jun 2021 3:16PM

why single out twitter though? aren't all of the US tech platforms doing this?

Pirate PraveenWed 16 Jun 2021 4:05PM

Internet Freedom Foundation has a more nuanced take on this https://nitter.eu/internetfreedom/status/1405039411008442370/

"Even if we presume that the IT Rules are legal and constitutional, where alleged non-compliance is for appointment of officers etc., when companies like Twitter are prosecuted, courts will decide if it is an intermediary and not the government."

Pirate VikWed 16 Jun 2021 5:50PM

Governments often interpret the law of the land in a certain way and get it wrong. The judicial system is there to keep checks and balance. If twitter is indeed wrong, they will lose in court, similarly if the governments action is not in line with the constitution as decided by the supreme court, they will lose. This takes time, we should await the outcome that the law of the land decide.