COllaborative DEcision MAking (codema.in)

Pirate movement - what do you feel about the name?

Hash Singularity PublicSeen by 32

On hearing the title "pirate movement" the first few words that come into an indian common man's mind will be, pirated cds, evil minded people, violence, robbery etc. They are not that much attached to piratebay or torrents. Even if the aim is to promote freedom of expression, self organisation, free knowledge societies etc, the name does not seem to convey any positive ideology(in Indian context). In my opinion this do require a "re-branding" at-least in terms of a catchy positive tag line.

Pirate Praveen

@hashsingularity can you suggest a tag line?

Sooraj Kenoth

ആംആദ്മി ആയാല്‍ പോലും കേന്ദ്രീകൃതമായ പരമ്പരാഗത ചുറ്റുപാടിലേക്കാണ് ആളുകളെ വലിച്ചിടുന്നത്. അതിന് അഴിമതി തുടങ്ങി നിലവിലുള്ള ചട്ടകൂട്ടിലെ പോരായ്മോട് യുദ്ധം ചെയ്ത് ആളുകളെ കൂടുതല്‍ അന്ധരാക്കുന്നു.
നമ്മള്‍ പുതിയ ഒരു വഴി തെളിക്കുകയാണ്. പണാധിപത്യത്തില്‍ നിന്ന് ജീവിക്കാനുള്ള വഴിയിലേക്ക്...

Akhil G

I agree with the OP, it was the first thought that came to my mind when I heard of this name that people are going to misunderstand the movements intentions.Unless we really convince them, people will generally have the impression, that this is possibly illegal stuff.

Pirate Praveen

@akhilg wouldn't it be better to have people joining us convinced by our ideas rather than just the name?

All the existing parties have good names, but is that enough?

Also calling ourselves pirates is a challenge to people who think we will stop sharing knowledge if we are called pirates.

Pirate Praveen

Also for people who care more about name than ideas they can see millions of "good named" organizations around. If name is an excuse not to join us, it is good that we don't have them.

Jinesh

@praveenarimbrathod I think this name is ambiguous, what about adding a tag line too, which convey our intentions?.

Jinesh

Though i didn't mean to say that name/tag line is more important than our ideas.

Pirate Praveen

@jinesh how about "Freedom fighters of the Digital Age"? @hashsingularity what do you think?

Jinesh

@praveenarimbrathod looks good, but lets wait for some more suggestions.

Pirate Praveen

"Defend our freedoms in the digital age"

Pirate Praveen

@neelgupta I don't like the tone of generosity, it feels like the person giving is superior. We should think of like peers sharing where the respect is mutual.

Neel Gupta

Generosity in Knowledge is not just about giving knowledge to others, you also get to take knowledge others too.

In other words, one generous person does not create a generous community.

Pirate Praveen

Knowledge is a right of everyone, you don't need any generosity to take what is rightfully yours.

Neel Gupta

1) you take Knowledge when someone shares it.
2) you take Knowledge when you buy book, movie, etc.
3) you cultivate Knowledge through meditation.

So how do you take Knowledge that is not given ?
I would rather say "Access to free Knowledge is a universal right."

Pirate Praveen

1) Knowledge is not anyone's private property. People are just carriers of knowledge.
2) these are packaging of knowledge
3) I don't think that is true. Through meditation you focus and it can help you in learning.

All knowledge should be free, and no one should be denied access to any knowledge.