Creating FSCI Manifesto
Original context https://codema.in/d/6Oe38XUT/proposing-fsciconf-as-a-more-free-software-aligned-national-conference/3
Current status: Draft: ready for vote; please respond to the poll with your stand and any requested changes.
When the Free Software movement began in 1984 by Richard Stallman, it was a response to proprietary software gaining momentum. Sharing software was the norm before. In those days, the challenges were limited to the development and use of the software itself.
We have now progressed greatly on that aspect when it comes to general purpose software. We have the GNU/Linux operating system (such as Debian, Ubuntu, Fedora), the Mozilla Firefox web browser, the LibreOffice/Only Office suites, the VLC media player, GIMP image editor, Blender animation suite and many others. But we now face challenges of a different nature, such as -
-
Practical difficulties with respect to modifying software (e.g. poor documentation, large code-base, inaccessible code architecture, etc) — this is applicable to all software. Web browsers and Android /smartphone operating systems in particular are large and complex, and depend on companies like Google for maintenance.
Traditionally in many Free Software projects, development is driven by developers and many times features that excites developers gets priority over what users need. This creates a disconnect between users and developers. Sometimes users demand specific features from volunteers, which also adds to the disconnect.
Some Free Software is developed by businesses and are driven by profit motives, so in those projects also users priorities are linked to profits. If we want users to be able to prioritize features, we need platforms to collectively raise funds and compensate our developers. This way developers can dedicate time which they otherwise have to give for work that sustains their living, as opposed to only dedicating free time.
Prav (for messaging) and DEPHCOM (for smartphone Operating System) are two such experiments from our community members to bring users to drive development direction of Free Software projects. We encourage more such experiments in different areas of Free Software.
-
Usability issues due to complex, unpleasant, or non-intuitive interfaces. Technological advancements have let to its adoption by many more people, and part of what made this possible is design that made interactions intuitive without having to learn the technical concepts behind them. On a related note, attention has been given to making things look pleasing to the eye, something which is culturally as well as technically driven.
Free Software projects have a tendency to be driven by software developers leading to less attention given to design and usability which inadvertently leads to a steep learning curve for new users. In these projects, buttons and options, that make things work, however badly placed or planned, are often passed as acceptable. This ends up driving people towards nonfree software that is usually easier to understand and more pleasant to use than Free counterparts.
Some efforts have been made towards this end by projects like GNOME and Penpot that have dedicated design teams.
-
Platform dependency when essential tools and services opt to become "app based" rather than making a webapp or using other established standards that make them accessible to a wider variety of devices. Usually, this means supporting only a narrow set of proprietary operating systems like Android and iOS. Even when it is technically capable of running on similar systems (such as LineageOS or Waydroid), the software is often programmed to detect a so-called "unapproved" setup and refuse to run.
Given the high prevalence of such practices, this creates barriers to anyone wanting to use more freedom-respecting operating systems and platforms, or who want to use the service using a more customised device such as an epaper tablet or a feature phone. Essential services like banking and ticketing are some examples of huge hurdles, but there are also numerous smaller ones, such as vending machines or luggage lockers that require the installation of a proprietary app designed for a proprietary platform in order to function.
-
Network effects that prevent running modified versions of software (e.g. Signal, and other centralized social-network based software). For this reason, privacy and decentralization have become as important as the software license. Unlike general purpose software like an Operating System or Office suite, software that depends on servers to mediate between users, we not only require users, but also maintain the servers (for example Video Conferencing or Online Office suites), and additionally become activists when it comes platforms with network effects/vendor lock-in (for example messaging platforms).
We at FSCI have been providing communications and collaboration platforms for many years, but it has not been really sustainable without heroic efforts from a few people. Thus, we recommend and promote better models like the Prāv cooperative, where more people take responsibility and commitment, the financial burden is more evenly shared, peoples' time and efforts are financially compensated, and decisions are taken democratically as a cooperative.
-
Locked-down hardware. All software is ultimately useless without hardware to run on. While the decades since 1984 have seen a lot of freedom-respecting and hackable hardware, there is also an increasing trend of locking down devices and only allowing so-called "authorised" operating systems or applications to run on them.
As an immediate example, one only has to observe that (almost) every laptop allows you to pick up and run (almost) any operating system of your choice, but the smartphone world has various hurdles ranging from arbitrary restrictions like "unlocking" the bootloader, to requiring approval from some self-appointed authority or other before being allowed to develop apps. Worryingly, rather than removing such restrictions, the trend seems to be to attempt to do this on laptops and other computing devices as well.
-
Adverse environmental and social impact. The trend of expecting hardware to be replaced every few years leads to an enormous amount of e-waste. To avoid this, we will prefer hardware that is durable, repairing and long-lasting so it does not need to be thrown away (or even recycled) every few years.
As a corollary, we will push back against the trend of software becoming increasingly bloated: a trend which is encouraged in part due to laziness combined with the attitude that "hardware is getting faster anyway". The lighter the software, the longer people can keep running it without upgrading their hardware.
These inefficiencies are present not just on the end-device but further down the chain as well. Fixing this means paying attention to things such as: tools that restart a download right from the beginning each time they're interrupted, instead of caching a partial version; streaming services which encourage re-downloading media every time they're accessed rather than storing and caching it.
A major category includes irresponsible deployment of large-scale, resource-intensive software whose costs far outweigh their benefits. These include: cryptocurrencies that spark an arms race towards ever larger computing setups to achieve the same end results; and diffusion models and Large Language Models (LLMs) that drain entire regions of their water, necessitate the creation of new power plants, and undo decades of work put towards alleviating the effects of climate change.
Diversity and inclusion. We want to be welcoming to diverse set of contributors with different set of life experiences and social barriers in everyday life. We need to provide a safe and respectful space for collaboration without allowing any kind of discrimination while participating in our communities. We have a Code of Conduct (https://fsci.in/code-of-conduct/) and take it very seriously.
-
Recognition of the political nature of technology. We believe that technology, with the great impact it can have on society, in inherently political, and that trying to be "apolitical" is the same as perpetuating the status quo. If that status quo happens to be sexist or fascist, for example, that is not something we want to be perpetuating.
Being political does not necessarily mean being politicians or trying to convince people to vote for you. Neither does it mean supporting or opposing one political party or another.
Rather, in this context, it means having goals and ideas about how technology can best be made to improve society—such as the goals and ideas laid out in this manifesto—and keeping them in our consciousness as we work towards them.
While we will not choose to support or collaborate with projects based on politics alone, this philosophy means that politics will necessarily be one of the many factors we take into account. In other words, our evaluation of technical merits of initiatives will include, to the extent appropriate, the politics behind them and the community around them. Conversely, we will articulate our own ideas, philosophies, and motivations on the projects we initiate.
-
Lack of awareness. When people are not informed of the political nature of the tools they use, there is a tendency to select software solutions based on superficial looks and functionality alone. This leaves the door open for exploitation as vendors have a free hand to make user-hostile changes with limited pushback. In this situation, people end up choosing solutions that, though apparently better, end up in the long run to be detrimental to themselves or to society at large.
The solution is to actively educate people on the social structures behind the software they choose. Emphasis should be placed on the fact that, because most of the requisite knowledge hinges on social and legal background, such choices can be made without requiring detailed technical knowledge, and in many cases without any technical knowledge at all. As a corollary, care should be taken from our end not to make assumptions about technical proficiency, and to modulate the level of technicality in our outreach to one which the audience at hand is comfortable with.
Therefore,
In addition to promoting Free Software ideas, the Free Software Community of India wants to be at the forefront of addressing challenges as they come up, and to take the community forward to achieve user freedom not merely on their personal devices, but on platforms and public infrastructure as well.
At the same time, we acknowledge the newer challenges are harder and require more patience and understanding from all of us.
We will make efforts to reach out to people beyond the technical circles that tend to form the majority of movements like ours. We will aim to collaborate with movements, both inside and outside of software related communities, who share our goals.
-
We will use Free Software powered platforms for our own organizing and promotion, and will be careful about our presence on proprietary platforms. If we are present or bridged to such platforms, the primary goal should be to bring people to Free Software and decentralized replacements. This would involve limited promotion of proprietary platforms in our other online presences like websites or Fediverse handles.
Proprietary presence should prominently advertise and encourage people to move to our preferred alternatives, but our preferred channels should not advertise the proprietary options.
We support projects like Wikipedia and OpenStreetMap that provides Free Knowledge and Free Map data. We also support projects like Cryptpad that are designed as public goods, using Free Software and offering privacy for users.
Given that many broader social, environmental, and economic issues related to technology are complex to navigate, we support the Permacomputing Principles and will use them as a guide along with this manifesto to help us evaluate new developments on a case-by-case basis.
Contributors/reviewers: Akshay S Dinesh, Pirate Praveen, Badri/Hippo, Fugata, Ravi Dwivedi, Pirate King, Kishy
Original context https://codema.in/d/6Oe38XUT/proposing-fsciconf-as-a-more-free-software-aligned-national-conference/3
Pirate PraveenFri 10 Oct 2025 4:37PM
@Badri Sunderarajan how about changing
If we are present or bridged to such platforms, the primary goal should be to promote Free Software and decentralized replacements.
to
If we are present or bridged to such platforms, the primary goal should be to bring people to Free Software and decentralized replacements, this would involve limited promotion of proprietary platforms in our online presence like website or fedi handles. So proprietary presence should prominently advertise and encourage people to move to our preferred replacements, but our preferred channels should not advertise the proprietary options.
What does FSCI meant to you?
proposal by Badri Sunderarajan Closed Sat 18 Oct 2025 3:00AM
Thanks to those of you who wrote your personal views about FSCI and what it means to you. A lot of the views matched with various aspects of the manifesto, especially related to software freedom and user control.
However, one recurring aspect I noticed is that of community. This ranges from people who experience FSCI mainly through the group chat as a way to keep up with tech news and hang out with like-minded people, to those who recognise that we can go beyond talk to work on specific solutions to improve things. That "we" does not necessarily mean everybody: it is not like we have a leadership structure where a few people make the decisions for everyone else to follow. Rather, the community forms a pool of like-minded people who can reach out to each other to start their own initiatives.
So far, we have been focusing on digging deeper and taking action, and while that's important, the more casual discussions and debates we have on the group are equally important: that's what enables us to get to know each other better and for new people to gradually get introduced to the community. I wonder if this needs to be highlighted in some way in the manifesto. For example, the "Diversity and inclusion" section talks about "contributors" but not about community members in general. That same section also does not explain or justify the Code of Conduct; we obviously have some rationale behind having one.
The above is what stood out to me most, but I invite you to engage with the other responses and draw your own insights as well.
What is the decision you need to make?
We are close to finalising the FSCI manifesto. Until now, we have been approaching the manifesto from the perspective of the community as a whole.
Before putting it to vote, I'd like to do a small low-effort exercise where you down what FSCI means to you, at a personal level.
Why is this important?
Going through this exercise could help to pick out points that we missed, as well as give a better sense of what most people care about. So, it would help to put the finishing touches on the manifesto.
What you need to do
Write three or more sentences about what FSCI as a community means to you, personally, or what you hope to enable through it.
A sentence can be one word long.
Your response can be the same as someone else's, as long as you type it out again rather than say "same as X person".
If you already wrote about this elsewhere, feel free to link or copy-paste it here.
Having less than three points is okay. Just figure out a way to say it in three or more sentences 😉
What you do not need to do
Reading the draft manifesto first is optional. It's okay to repeat what is included there.
Reading other responses first is optional. It's okay to repeat what is included there, too.
The point does not have to be very deep or well formatted. I would suggest writing the first thing that comes to your head, and then coming back and editing the response if you think of something better later.
"I want to use software without paying" is also a point. (Hopefully you have more points than that one!)
If you don't have access to Codema or find it more convenient to use the group chat, you can put your responses there and tag me (badrihippo).
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| FSCI is important to me because... | 7 | 88 | 3 | ||
| I have no clue about FSCI, someone just added me here | 1 | 13 | 0 | ||
| Undecided | 261 | 97 |
Badri Sunderarajan
Sat 11 Oct 2025 4:03AM
I want control over the hardware and software that I use. That includes physical control (being able to repair and modify things myself) as well as social control (being able to use services of my choice without being pressured by what others use). Turns out I'm not alone in wanting those things :D
Tanzeem Mohammad Basheer
Sat 11 Oct 2025 4:03AM
FSCI means to me
As a platform for collaborative efforts in promotion of Free Software
A platform to get collective inputs for involving in govt decision making process concerned to technology and free Software
Building alternative systems to protect the privacy, safety and freedom of the people
Raise voice against misuse or wrong use of software and protest strongly to see the right way is used
Indulge in intervention in the right time for adoption of technologies in govt level
Educating public, students and professionals in govt and private and entrepreneurs, company ctos about the importance of using free Software and adopting efficient data protection laws.
Promotion activities to bring more people to FSCI for stronger efforts to see necessary changes across the state.
Clear my doubts and get educated about what I may not know from others in the community
To foster a sense of togetherness in working for the good of the people of India.
Pirate Praveen
Sat 11 Oct 2025 4:03AM
The original idea was to have a place to list many local Free Software user groups across India. This was started as FOSS Community India (fci.wikia.com).
When poddery.com diaspora instance was shutting down, we got together to save it through save.poddery.com campaign. Since then many Free Software services were added like matrix, xmpp, gitlab ce, loomio, mailman 3, peertube, etc.
Now we are exploring the possibility of national level event / meetup driven by community and focusing on Free Software ideas / philosophy (as opposed to Open Source / practical / career / product development focus of IndiaFOSS).
We also organized online camps during covid to mentor students to start contributing to Free Software.
Ravi Dwivedi
Sat 11 Oct 2025 4:03AM
An inclusive community which spreads the free software philosophy. A gateway to make free software accessible (by running services such as poddery.com so that ordinary users don't have to self-host to get freedom and privacy, although those services might not be in an ideal state). Anarchy.
Akshay
Sat 11 Oct 2025 4:03AM
It's an anarchic group with (presently) a vague commitment to critically think about software ownership and society. Accordingly what I feel about it keeps changing depending on who's active in it and what they find interesting in that point of time. I've learned a lot of software development, sysadmin, and anarchic organizing skills here.
perry
Sat 11 Oct 2025 4:03AM
FSCI to me is the XMPP group where people share cool links and talk about software and hardware freedom. Having a CoC for a community is important to me and I like that people here encourage you to use inclusive language. I got to know many new people and ideas from the community and it feels good to know there are people around me trying to make software and knowledge open and helping people take control of software and hardware. Also, apart from the fediverse it is my source of news for all things happening in technology and software
Life is Tetris
Sat 11 Oct 2025 4:03AM
I occasionally throw in my 2 paise in some Loomio discussions, and once did some Prav intro simplification (also paid a month's hosting fees for some service once - miniscule); it is out of gladness that atleast some Indians are discussing software implications for our part of the world.
I hope FSCI can decentralize free/libre/open software commons infrastructure, by hosting dev services for India. The government https://openforge.gov.in is an example, a better one than Savannah. Hosting more public services like Prav seems a tall order though.
Ideally, FSCI would think post-colonially and come up with open solutions from a purely Indian point of view (like the government has been doing with, e.g. UPI). It does not imply NIH syndrome; just as the colonizers learnt from India in the past, we can learn from Europe (e.g. Delta Chat's UX driven design), NZ (Loomio is great!), etc. but create solutions that matter. e.g. why is it so difficult to type in Indian languages on smartphones? Why is Indian language text (Unicode) wastefully heavy when there have been alternatives like ISCII?
sahilister
Sat 11 Oct 2025 4:03AM
As someone long back said, one of the major contribution of FSF to the world were GPL/copyleft license. In a similar tone, I would say one major thing which FSCI (is to me) is a community of like minded folks who (more of less) believe in Free Software, privacy and activism of various kinds hence it's the FSCI "community" part which I identify FSCI with. A place to discuss, ideate and debate.
We have been kind-of been successful in managing Free Software services like mailing lists, Jitsi Meet, Poddery (for a long time indeed) and organizing it under FSCI banner was a major win.
So, I see FSCI as meeting place of fellow Free Software hackers and enthusiasts, who also manage a few Free Software services on the sideline, encouraging their usage.
Ravi DwivediSat 11 Oct 2025 4:49PM
Unfortunately, I summed up my thoughts in two sentences 😕
Item removed
Badri SunderarajanTue 18 Nov 2025 4:17AM
I think the draft is finalised except for the LLM section which @fugata wanted to add to and which I also think needs to be clarified more. I've started a discussion on this in the group chat and will report back here on Thursday.
Adopt the FSCI Manifesto
proposal by Badri Sunderarajan Closed Fri 13 Mar 2026 12:00AM
After many weeks (months?) of intense discussion, the final FSCI manifesto has been accepted unanimously! Thanks to everyone who participated!
We can now proceed to publicise this, and refer to its values in future decisions we make.
(Of course, this is a living document so anyone wanting changes to the manifesto is welcome to start a new thread for their specific requested changes)
What is the decision you need to make?
Accepting the FSCI Manifesto (in the first post of this thread).
Why is this important?
This will help to clarify our stance when other people ask for it, and also help give a direction to our own activities going forward.
Specifically, we are going to be using it as a reference for (and probably promoting it widely in?) the FSCI Conference as discussed in this thread.
What are you asking people to do?
Read through the manifesto and see if it is acceptable to you. We can always add further refinements later (which will again go through vote) but you should be okay with the principles as they have been outlined so far. If you have any concerns or would like to change certain things, you can include that in your vote.
For this proposal to pass, we need the majority of voting members to vote Agree.
If you Disagree, say why and what needs to change for you to Agree.
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agree | 6 | 100 | 2 | ||
| Abstain | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Disagree | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Block | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Undecided | 269 | 98 |
Badri Sunderarajan
Thu 26 Feb 2026 9:47AM
I am not very happy with the endorsement of Public AI (publicai.co). Even though they have better standards than most LLM/diffusion-model providers, the models they use still have hidden or hard-to-access sources.
I would prefer to apply the same standards to "Free Software LLMs" and "Free Software diffusion models" as we do to any other Free Software, i.e. that all the assets required to compile the program are available (in this case, it would include the training data) as argued here.
Do we really need to add them as an example? In my opinion, other things listed like "designed as public goods, using Free Software and offering privacy for users" already applies to the other listed projects like OpenStreetMap and Wikipedia. We could also add Marginalia. Unless the point is that the services do not necessarily have to be running Free Software in which case we can put Mojeek...but I don't think we want to make that point either. If this is only to do with LLMs, then as discussed in the FSCI group, we can also release a separate statement on "AI" later outlining our stance on LLMs and diffusion models (and maybe also Markov models, etc.)
(Would be good if whoever added Public AI to the manifesto can respond here with the reason for adding it)
Pirate PraveenThu 26 Feb 2026 1:40PM
@Badri Sunderarajan I added public AI. I think it is a mistake to think all Free Software used everywhere can be treated equally. Depending on the complexity and cost, we have to apply different criteria to effectively resist proprietary software. A software like calculator that can run by itself on any device cannot be reasonably compared to a software that needs a server always running (client server software), a server always running and your network in it (federation), or a search engine or LLM that needs huge computing power and storage. To say everything has be run on our personal devices, however complicated the situation is, a bit naive. This kind of blind extrapolation of software that runs on a small personal device to every software without considering the complexity is preventing us from providing an effective response to proprietary software in new areas. New challenges need new thought and strategy - like we will need more collective/social/organization efforts than we did in the past with software that runs isolated on a small personal device. Though if more people want to remove Public AI and create a separate document for LLMs, that is fine for me too.
Pirate Praveen
Thu 26 Feb 2026 9:47AM
I'm ok to remove Public AI to a dedicated LLM document if everyone thinks that way.
Badri Sunderarajan
Thu 26 Feb 2026 5:22PM
This sounds like a solid manifesto, and is definitely an improvement on our previous one (which was afaik identical to the British Constitution 😉)
We can certainly make more editorial improvements, but now that the unqualified reference to Public AI has been removed, this is a good enough starting point to at least have a manifesto in place, and I have no further objections to adopting this.
kishyThu 26 Feb 2026 10:19AM
If we want users to be able to prioritize features, we need platforms to collectively raise funds and hire developers
I would prefer to change "hire developers" to "compensate our developers". I think the latter has better connotation of collective ownership.
kishyThu 26 Feb 2026 10:40AM
Free Software projects have a tendency to be driven by tech enthusiasts leading to less attention given to design and usability: if there are buttons or options to make things work, however badly placed, they are often passed as acceptable. This ends up driving people to nonfree software that is easier to understand and more pleasant to use.
Free Software projects have a tendency to be driven by software developers leading to less attention given to design and usability which inadvertently leads to a steep learning curve for new users: if there are buttons or options to make things work, however badly placed or planned, they are often passed as acceptable. This ends up driving people to nonfree software that is easier to understand and more pleasant to use. A popular example of the same is people avoiding free creative software to use Adobe Software.
kishyThu 26 Feb 2026 10:49AM
I am hoping we can create a shorter version of the same and include relevant points to the FSCI about page (separate from the manifesto page). It could prove helpful in easily sharing and communicating what FSCI's core ethos and philosophies are.
kishyThu 26 Feb 2026 10:51AM
Large Language Models (LLMs) that drain entire regions of their water
Would be nice to add sources for all the claims made throughout the document
AkshayThu 26 Feb 2026 5:11PM
I'm finding it very hard to figure out how to think about LLMs. The more I read about why LLMs are bad, I end up thinking how software (any software) itself seems like a bad idea. Where to draw the line? Shouldn't we all adopt degrowth? And what does that mean? And so on... Therefore I would be okay with adopting a manifesto which doesn't include a specific position on LLMs/AI.
Pirate PraveenTue 31 Mar 2026 11:25AM
Anyone wants to publish this on our website?
Can you volunteer to post our manifesto on the FSCI website?
proposal by Badri Sunderarajan Closed Sun 5 Jul 2026 5:00AM
Thanks to @Dhruva Punde for volunteering unanimously to publish the manifesto on the FSCI website!
What are you asking people to do?
Publish the manifesto on the FSCI website. (We have already edited and voted on this following numerous rounds of discussion, so please publish as-is without performing any further edits. If there are edits you think should be made, they can be brought up in a separate discussion. Incidentally, this reduces the amount of work you would have to perform 😉)
Why is this important?
The FSCI Manifesto has been finalised by the community nearly 3 months ago, but we are yet to announce it publicly. It is good to have the official policy on our website for people to refer to.
What are you asking people to do?
Volunteer to publish the manifesto. Or if you can't, help us reach out and find someone who can. It is a small task so one person should be enough to do it; the main reason for this poll is to draw attention to the unfinished task as nobody noticed it when it was just a comment 🙃
Results
| Results | Option | Votes | % of votes cast | % of eligible voters | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I will publish the manifesto | 1 | 100 | 0 | ||
| I will find someone else to publish this | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||
| Undecided | 279 | 100 |
Deep PandyaSun 5 Jul 2026 3:59PM
Nice to see the manifesto published on the site.
Akshay ·Fri 10 Oct 2025 7:50AM
@Badri Sunderarajan
How does slightly rephrasing to the following sound?