COllaborative DEcision MAking (codema.in)

Statement on Tooter: The 'swadeshi' twitter alternative

Pirate Praveen PublicSeen by 27

Tooter.in [1] is just copying Free Software and shamelessly calling it 'Made in India'. It is made by people from around the world and shared freely.

Either they did not write even a single line or they are violating the Affero GPL copyright license, which requires them to publish their changes. They are linking to original code in gab project repos (which is a fork of mastodon).

Even the terms of service is just copied with references to first amendment in the USA.

Free Software allows anyone to use, share, modify and redistribute software. But you are still required to follow the specific conditions of the copyright license. You cannot claim copyright to code written by others.

This is not the first instance of such false claims. It has become a trend to take Free Software, falsely and shamelessly claim as 'Made in India', without writing even a single line of code. Beware of such frauds and promote the Free Software idea, if you notice such instances.

[1] https://indianexpress.com/article/technology/social/meet-tooter-the-swadeshi-answer-to-twitter-everything-you-need-to-know-7063883/

Publish this statement on Tooter on our website

proposal by Pirate Praveen Closed Sat 28 Nov 2020 6:00PM

Tooter.in [1] is just copying Free Software and shamelessly calling it 'Made in India'. It is made by people from around the world and shared freely.

Either they did not write even a single line or they are violating the Affero GPL copyright license, which requires them to publish their changes. They are linking to original code in gab project repos (which is a fork of mastodon).

Even the terms of service is just copied with references to first amendment in the USA.

Free Software allows anyone to use, share, modify and redistribute software. But you are still required to follow the specific conditions of the copyright license. You cannot claim copyright to code written by others.

This is not the first instance of such false claims. It has become a trend to take Free Software, falsely and shamelessly claim as 'Made in India', without writing even a single line of code. Beware of such frauds and promote the Free Software idea, if you notice such instances.

[1] https://indianexpress.com/article/technology/social/meet-tooter-the-swadeshi-answer-to-twitter-everything-you-need-to-know-7063883/

Results

Pirate Praveen
Agree

I think this would be a good opportunity to explain Free Software and the idea of people all over the world collaboratively building software to challenge big corporations controlling software and collecting personal data.

Pirate Bady

here's another example:

CPI(M) leaders said the online video conferencing tool was developed two months ago for internal party meetings. Two Polit Bureau meetings were held using the in-house tool during the lockdown.

They said the tool developed by the CPI(M) for internal use is secure and has robust privacy settings.

https://www.deccanherald.com/national/coronavirus-cpim-uses-own-video-tool-for-cc-meet-cpi-leaders-meets-on-zoom-865739.html

they didn't use 'made in india' label explicitly, but some media reported it as 'developed' by CPI(M). the so-called in-house developed app is actually BigBlueButton (screenshots here). the problem here's also with the media as they do not care enough to verify the claims or their tech teams don't understand the difference between 'developing' and 'self-hosting'.