When to Reject Nonfree JavaScript?
I agree with Stallman's "The JavaScript Trap" (https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/javascript-trap.html) when it comes to the issue, but I have a different opinion when it comes to the rest of the article. Just wrote a blog post about it: https://nandakumar.org/blog/2026/09/nonfree-js.html
AkshayWed 23 Sep 2026 2:36AM
I agree with your criticism of stallman's view on this and I want to take it one step further.
The whole free software movement is a bait and switch.
What we really care about is user freedom so that they can do with their devices what they want. We don't really care about licenses. Stallman first ties user freedom to license, then ties license to librejs, and then rejects any site that doesn't conform to that. What we should reject is simply sites that hamper user freedom.
DerpitronSat 26 Sep 2026 1:43PM
@Akshay To be clear, I don't think Stallman or GNU are license-fanatics either. The GPL was designed as an exploit of copyright law but in order to provide users more rights, rather than take them away, as is conventional for EULAs.
At the base layer, the nation's consumer rights, doctrine of first sale, and copyright fair dealing exceptions with respect to software must be expanded in order to give citizens more rights and protections in the first place, rigorously enforced until companies financially/legally fear violating those user rights. The problem is copyright, especially as it applies to software today. If copyright didn't exist, the GPL wouldn't need to exist, just like how a person who recovers from an injury no longer needs a crutch.
With this in mind, taking into account how horrible modern copyright law is, I can't blame Stallman for being fanatic, and I think assuming he is a license-purist who doesn't care about the underlying legal system which he believes necessitates license-purism is misinterpreting his ideology.
AkshaySat 26 Sep 2026 3:11PM
@Derpitron to extend your analogy, a person who recovers from injury needs not just crutch, they need food, medicines, air, water, support, friends, etc, etc. If someone is being a crutch-purist, they don't really care about the person or their recovery.
DerpitronSat 26 Sep 2026 5:53PM
@Akshay True, that's why Linus Torvalds recommended people support the EFF over the FSF, regarding the controversy over why Linux didn't switch over to GPL3.
The EFF has been continually lobbying and trying to file court cases against the provisions of DMCA 1201 (the root of nearly all technological evil) as well as the various other legal rights bases I mentioned, in America. (Unfortunately in India there is no momentum or movement regarding this yet. Indian precedent isn't really clear.)
Either way the terms of the (A)GPL3 are so explicitly good and user respecting that there's no point not blindly using them today for FOSS.
AkshayWed 23 Sep 2026 2:40AM
In Malayalam there's this story of the kid who is asked to write 10 points about coconut tree. She writes
We tie cow to coconut tree
Cow gives us milk
Milk gives us butter
Butter can be used for making curry
Curry can be eaten with chappatti.
...
...
Stallman's arguments are like that.
We need freedom to modify and share software
Free license allows 1
Anything that doesn't have free license is evil
JavaScript needs to include license in it
Librejs can block JavaScript that doesn't conform to 4
Sites should work with librejs
By point 2 itself we've lost the plot
Nandakumar Edamana ·Wed 23 Sep 2026 1:34AM
Pasting the conclusion since I don't want anyone to force visit my blog:
So, here is my final criteria:
Browsing and reading: always disable JavaScript; HTML and CSS are sufficient for online articles and documentation.
General-purpose Web Apps: first, do it offline as much as possible. Offline or online, Free JavaScript is a must for Web apps.
Specific services (like netbanking): I don’t care if the JS is free or not, for I have no other use for it. Ensuring privacy is a different issue.
Others’ computing: running nonfree JS from a cloud service that your employer adopted to get their computing done (preferably on their machine) is also okay, but help them migrate eventually.