Indian Pirates should campaign against the use of meat as a food source
Meat as a food source for humans is unsustainable at a world population size of 7 billion and climbing.
Animal Agriculture is responsible for 18% of greenhouse gas emissions - that's more than all vehicle exhaust combined. (United Nations - http://www.fao.org/docrep/010/a0701e/a0701e00.HTM)
Water Consumption for Animal Agriculture ranges between 34-76 trillion gallons annually.
Livestock or livestock feed occupies 1/3 of the earth’s ice-free land.
Animal agriculture is the leading cause of species extinction, ocean dead zones, water pollution, and habitat destruction.
82% of the world’s starving children live in countries where food is fed to animals that are then killed and eaten by more well off individuals in developed countries.
India produced 2681000 tonnes of meat in 2013 (https://data.gov.in/catalog/stateut-wise-estimates-meat-production).
Beef production consumes on average 4 million gallons of water per tonne.
Vegetable production consumes 85,000 gallons of water per tonne.
We currently grow enough grain on the planet to feed a population of 10 billion - no one needs to be without food.
So are you making a case against Meat or against Beef, the latter has my complete opposition. I think let's not be myopic and hurriedly take sides in the food debate, we need to look deeper into what is consumed by whom and why. Before expecting people to change.
There are greater evils to fight, cigarettes, Processed Foods & even Kinder Joy (I hate that damn thing).
@alexandergounder I am making the case against meat on the basis of sustainability as a food source. This is not isolating any one meat product. I guess I am trying to make the case based on science and statistics rather than ideology or religion (which seems to be grabbing all of the headlines!)
The problem has to be viewed from multiple perspectives. As @praveenarimbrathod said, some of the most vulnerable sections of the society depend on meat for their diet. We also have to think whether we can have a situation where the food prices (especially vegetable prices) sky rocketting on one side, and trying to discourage non-vegetarian diet on the other side. I don't think we can address the latter without solving the former.
@athulgeorgeappadan Vegetable prices are rocketing due to insufficient supply. Insufficient supply because much more resources are taken up by animal agriculture. These two problems are linked - take out one and you solve the other. I cannot fathom how vulnerable or poor people are surviving on meat when it costs so much more than vegetables to produce.
I think the real culprit of high priced vegetables is likely lack of resource - as that resource is being used for meat export.
@vik I would like to disagree on the assumption that the rocketing vegetable prices is because of lack in supply. Eventhough it is a plausible case, many reports hae come in ecent times which suggest otherwise.
http://www.livemint.com/Opinion/tZuQGCgP3Ldcf5fPITMHcI/The-curious-case-of-rising-onion-prices.html
@vik : great observation! .. Had no idea that animal agriculture could cause greenhouse emission. Its quite interesting. Downloaded the pdf from the link you provided. Think you might have any links to videos related to what you are talking about?
edit: found it - COWSPIRACY Documentary full : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=06yX3rjgLSo
If you dont wanna watch the 1.5 hr long documentary :
http://www.cowspiracy.com/facts/
@vik: im quite surprised how this never made it to mainstream media .. or did it?
@arjun watch all of the documentary, it covers exactly why this topic is not mainstream
@athulgeorgeappadan so they controlled supply in the case of onions to inflate the price. I take your point and agree that the market is manipulated for short term gains - but the scale of the problem with animal agriculture rather outweighs what traders are doing. I am sure they also manipulate meat prices, people do all sorts to make money! Still, if there were more land perhaps even greater supply would make manipulation more difficult.
@vik any citation to justify that claim? vegetable prices => less resource => due to more animal agriculture .. I want the science and statistics,on which you said earlier you are depending your argument on.
Can't the lack of supply in vegetables be accounted to other important factors, like land misuse etc, before we point towards animal agriculture? Banning meat seems to be against the natural way of human life, who were (and still are) omnivores.. Sure, situations changing would need man to adapt. But here, I don't think quitting meat eating is the agreeable compromise.
@balasankarchelamat If animal agriculture occupies 1/3 of the total ice free land on the planet - then I think it's pretty fair to say that would effect the supply and price of vegetables. The numbers (1/3 of all land) are colossal and in no way represent a "natural way" of human life.
Even if we talk about a natural way of life - meat consumption would usually be down to necessity - that is not where we are now - and it cannot feed 7 billion people.
"Impacts from agriculture are expected to increase substantially due to population growth and increasing consumption of animal products. Unlike fossil fuels, it is difficult to look for alternatives: people have to eat. A substantial reduction of impacts would only be possible with a substantial worldwide diet change, away from animal products."
http://www.unep.org/resourcepanel/Portals/24102/PDFs/PriorityProductsAndMaterials_Report.pdf
Additionally we should also give some thought to the fish
http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/sep/15/tuna-and-mackerel-populations-suffer-catastrophic-74-decline-research-shows
So, would people here agree with the suggestion of @praveenarimbrathod ? This could be a compromise that allows us to agree in a proposal. I would also accept the position of being against meat exports.
@praveenarimbrathod would you also adopt the same position for imports?
With another mob murder being reported today, I feel I have to reluctantly back down from my position so as not to link Indian Pirates with any of the sentiment of the Nationalist who seem hell bent on stoking communal violence in the name of their religious food preference. Shame really, but am digging my bunker ready for the post apocalyptic future. Ping me offline if you want a space in it!
All cattle, whether raised for milking, ploughing or the slaughterhouse, emit methane as part of their digestive process.
http://scroll.in/article/764422/
How much methane a cow belches depends on its diet. An assessment of methane emissions from cattle across India’s agro-ecological regions showed that cattle that were on production diets to optimize their breeding, milking or working emitted more methane than those on growth and maintenance diets.
India released as much carbon dioxide equivalent of greenhouse gas from its rice paddies in the period between 1990 and 2012 as its non-dairy cattle belched.
If methan IS such a big problem , why not use it to our benefit? ..
And it looks like there are people other than us who care about the same issue.. check this website out.. http://www.environmentalengineering.in/Biogas.htm
The Project has two parts.
Ist part Deals in separating impurities such as moisture, Carbon dioxide and Hydrogen sulfide and generating pure Methane from Biogas.
IInd part Deals in Filtering, compressing and filling Methane in a Gas Bottle i.e. a CNG Dispenser making it suitable as an IC Engine fuel.
@arjun good luck collecting that methane!
@praveenarimbrathod this is not an accurate comparison. You cannot for example, compare the CO2 output of rice production vs non diary cattle, without comparing the food output from both.
When you compare the actual amount of food produced from rice vs non diary cattle and then factor it against greenhouse gas production - you will see again that it makes no sense at all (in greenhouse gas terms) to use meat as a food source.
There are of course the remaining arguments of deforestation, river and sea pollution etc.
@vik you sound offended :| .. just so you know, my previous post wasn't meant to offend anyone
@vik , I cannot agree with you on "I think the real culprit of high priced vegetables is likely lack of resource - as that resource is being used for meat export.". Price of farm products in India is deeply linked to governance and economics. Government lure the farmers into producing in large quantities by promising them MSP. When they produce food government refuse to procure the product and farmers are left with no choice but to sell them to private wholesalers. Thus large quantity of food that should have been available at subsidised price is actually available at market price. Thus, the increase in price.
@abhijithb I think you can find local policies that will have upward impacts on the cost of vegetables - but we're talking here of a volume and scale that is global in nature.
If animal agriculture occupies 1/3 of all usable land (United Nations http://www.fao.org/newsroom/en/News/2006/1000448/index.html) but provides only around 8% of the world calorie intake (FAOSTAT, 2009) - can you understand how that effects supply/demand/price of crops?
I'll say it again for emphasis. 1/3 of all of the land on earth to provide 8% of the calorific intake of the world population - that's not smart, for anyone, anywhere.
@arjun I wasn't offended :) I was being a little sarcastic perhaps. But my point remains - great idea to use the methane - but virtually impossible to collect it!
World Health Organisation declares processed meats a category 1 carcinogen:
http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/oct/26/bacon-ham-sausages-processed-meats-cancer-risk-smoking-says-who
Now you wouldn't give your kids cigarettes for breakfast would you?
@vik , What about protien? http://www.whfoods.com/genpage.php?tname=nutrient&dbid=92
Also, "But my point remains - great idea to use the methane - but virtually impossible to collect it!"???
I have spent my entire childhood watching my neighbour cook food only using Bio Gas. It is very much possible.
While we debate the ill effects of meat products, we need to also understand the current situation, where meat bans are being made for a completely different reason, RELIGION.
If we ever reach a consensus against Meat we'll only be supplying reasons that this religious brigade can use to justify their Opposition to Meat as a Food Source, which stems from their very privileged sense of righteousness.
This thought has come to me in the last week or so, isn't Banning Meat or Beef equal to practicing Untouchability, because if what I consume something effects your sense of purity, that thought is on the same lines of Someone of higher caste feeling impure because of being touched by or having someones lower caste's shadow falling on them.
I know @vik is too evolved and hasn't got any Religious Agenda, Having met him, I am amply convinced he's no where close to the Saffron brigade that started banning meat.I didn't realize that @Vik was the same guy I met at SFD Mumbai hence my reactions of asking if he was doing this for religious reasons at the start of this thread. Just thought I put this out there...
My Point here is if we continue down this path and dig out logical, scientific reasons of why Meat shouldn't be used as food source, The only thing we could achieve is handing out a camouflage for the Saffron Brigade who want this for a totally different reason, and thus we'll be party to an evolved form of discrimination which can be equated to abolished (but continuing) forms of discrimination like untouchability. So in the interest of Social Justice, we should pause this discussion here.
thanks
Alex
@abhijithb ah - the old protein argument - I was wondering when that would rear is head. The major part of the protein argument actually comes from marketing by the meat industry - who have tried to frame this belief that somehow meat is required to get sufficient protein into a persons diet.
If you read the figures you have posted, you will see that soya bean is more protein dense than many meat products.
Here are more vegan foods that have more protein than beef:
http://www.onegreenplanet.org/natural-health/soy-free-vegan-foods-that-have-more-protein-than-beef/
@abhijithb As for BioGas - to be completely clear, what I am getting at here is - how are you going to collect the biogas from farting and belching animals?
I can think of developing a contraption for each animal to wear. I would suggest however, that it would better to have less grazing livestock and use some of that land to plan trees for fuel.
Timber for fuel is fairly carbon neutral if you replant after cutting down.
@vik how much is the calory value of a cow, if we include the milk into the equation.
I agree with @gounder , we cannot be blind to what is happening around us.
@gounder yeah - I am feeling what you are saying, but i am conflicted over which is the greater argument.
I made a comment last week after the latest "meat murder" https://www.loomio.org/comments/818980/
I remain conflicted though.
Yes, we can say this gives capital to the crazy brigade - but the environmental destruction and largest mass species extinction since the dinosaurs sort of make me feel like taking the argument away from the crazies and making it much more intellectual, factual / based in science.
If this is not a campaign for the Indian Pirates then I totally understand that, but I think this is exactly the sort of organisation that should challenge things like the meat ban but provide truth, facts and evidence.
The meat ban is pretty meaningless in regard to the scale of the problem - and those people have not even thought about the problem. It's knee jerk right wing politics at it's worst. But I am not sure that should silence us..
@praveenarimbrathod it depends on the breed - diary cows have been specifically bred for high yield. I don't think you can add these two things together easily.
Diary cows are generally different breeds than those used for meat.
@vik Most vegan food are poor sources of protein. For example, pulses regarded widely as protein source has only 25% protien by weight and 18% by DV. Soya may be more efficient than beef but it still does not rank as a top source of protien.
Bio Gas
My neighbour had a simple method of flushing cow dung from cattle shed into his bio gas plant. He even collected dung from the places he took his cows to rear for use as manure. Coincidentally, I and @praveenarimbrathod were joking that where does this methane problem come from? From farting cattle?
I think this sort of a campaign is unsustainable, disregards individual freedoms and is usually reliant on selective data.
Additionally, while we use milk, we cannot give up dairy. While we do dairy, we cannot prevent beef. If we have beef, no one in India will agree to banning anything else.
Relevant reading https://aamjanata.com/animal-husbandry-slaughter-and-economic-viability-in-five-images/
Regardless of the merits of the argument, IMO, India is not even ready for this debate.Campaigning will be a waste of tie on a non-debate.
@vidyut I concur, India does not seem ready for the debate. I am concerned for the future of my children however - they may no longer have the luxury to debate as they fight their neighbours for rations on a rapidly overheating planet.
India does not seem ready to debate female infanticide, rape inside and outside of marriage, homosexuality, gender discrimination and many many other things that are seemingly the domain of educated liberals.
@praveenarimbrathod If you oppose export of meat, it will mean opposing export of beef as well. India uses cows massively for dairy, has taboos about eating the meat and would WASTE all that ecologically expensive meat. This is already happening with the cow slaughter bans. Beef is the biggest export among meats (we eat mostly everything else).
@vidyut I agree, banning exports is not an option. It would also mean we break the interdependancy of nations. I withdraw my argument.
@vik Given the condition of the country, I am more worried that my kid will grow up an orphan because his mother pissed off the wrong people. We have worse and more urgent problems. To put it mildly. With or without meat, the problem with food is not supply, but the lack of equitable distribution. The world may be producing enough grains for all, but India is able to produce enough meat without having to import it, unlike grains. In other words, we aren't feeding our grains to our cows - the way the beef industry does in the west - for fattening for meat. Our meat production is largely a byproduct of our dairy industry. There are many facets to the debate, if one insists on having it. Using data from India is a bonus, because a lot of practices in India don't happen to the affluent and often wasteful standards of the west (which they can afford because prices are better + govt support is excellent).
For the record, most of the cattle feed in India is bran, oilseed cakes, green fodder, hay and straw. Most of which are either byproducts or grow in areas not occupied by crops (though sowing green fodder is increasing because of depleting public grazing because of land grabs and forests also because of land grabs, mining, industrialization, etc). In effect, India pretty much raises its meat on waste.
@gounder "The only thing we could achieve is handing out a camouflage for the Saffron Brigade who want this for a totally different reason"..... I second that
@vik This is not to say no grains are fed to livestock, but that they are used far less than you'd think from reading western statistics.
@gounder @arjun the saffron brigade using this as camouflage is probably the only useful thing from this debate, IMO. Have had it happen several times on Twitter. I let them dig themselves into a ditch establishing just how expensive dairy is. Then say since we won't give up milk, do you think the beef ban is ethical when it WASTES so many resources already spent on raising the meat? :p
@vidyut I thought india was a net exporter of meat to the rest of the world though?
I guess I pissed off the wrong people a long while back and they didn't come for me yet, so I'm feeling safer about it these days!
Anyway, I accept the overall point you make - this may not be the place for this particular debate at this moment in time.
If anyone else has anything to add please do - failing which I propose closing the thread.
@vidyut haha I think I know what you are talking about.. Nice one.. Also, I think you should type it out on detail what you were telling us the other night about why banning beef would be a stupid move and how it would affect the poor.. Was quite a thought.. But then this thread is not about beef ban..so maybe somewhere else.. Maybe a short article on aamjanata ?
@vidyut THAT WAS QUICK! :p.. Shall put on my reading glasses right away!
@vidyut there is cause for concern right there - resource went into those exports, I would argue that's wasteful. The majority of those animals are not a bi-product and I would suggest that the poultry particular would be grain fed in significant proportion.
As the economy grows more people will get into that export market - and like everywhere else - it's not unlikely that India will end up in a similar place re: land and resource usage by the meat industry.
@vik it ain't pissing off anyone if no one got pissed. It is merely stating an opinion that didn't bother them :p
Actually, @vik, those animals are most certainly a byproduct for dairy farming. Keeping the alive will consume more resources than killing them, and their creation cannot be prevented till we are able to have artificial insemination that only produces female offspring.
It is true poultry is grain fed. Most commonly hardy and excellently healthy Indian millets that grow pretty much anywhere and are (sadly) relatively less used for human consumption.
I support campaign to stop exporting meat. I'm still studying the issue from different perspectives. The data seems compelling but we need to consider other angles as well. Even if we stop eating meat, does that ensure poor people get food? The root cause of the issue for me is the current system that guarantee ad sustain inequalities. Also it should be a more nuanced approach, starting from the most severe and per capita consumption, cost of balanced veg-only diet etc.