COllaborative DEcision MAking (codema.in)

Free Software, Open Source, "cloud", lock-in, coc, feminist software etc

Pirate Praveen Tue 17 Nov 2026 4:48PMPublicSeen by 8

There are many topics that keeps coming up in the community in regular intervals. I want to look at these topics from a broader perspective.

  1. The original Free Software vs Open Source debate: This debate tries to limit or expand the scope of philosophy around the software that is built collaboratively and shared freely. The software actually produced remains more or less same, but what motivates people to use or develop differs between philosophies.

  2. Software moving to computers controlled by others ("cloud"): This is a new development initially not anticipated by Free Software or Open Source movements. To ensure freedom, we not only need to free the software that runs on our computers but also we need to manage software on the server. FSF completely missed this new development and chose to focus on front end javascript that still runs on our browsers. Communities like disroot, riseup and fsci try to address this by hosting services collectives. People also self host, but it needs skills, money for hosting and sustained effort to maintain.

  3. Additional constraint of network effects: Social Media adds yet another challenge on top of the services - even if we self host individually or collectively, our friends/family won't move. This needs even more tools than needed for self hosting challenge, in addition to running services, we need to actively market it too - something we are traditionally weak in doing. So we end up choosing the easier path of either not trying to move people out of centralized big tech or choosing to blame them for staying there. Prav is trying to change it, but so far Prav community is still small and it is hard to motivate people to think beyond traditional Free Software talking points and strategies.

  4. Diversity and inclusion of contributor identities: As people with different identities that are traditionally discriminated by larger society became involved in Free Software, expanding Free Software to cover these issues came up naturally. This could still work as communities can still decide rules within their communities and enforce them. Code of Conduct became part of many communities.

  5. Ethical Software, Feminist Software etc: Now people want to take software to achieve goals beyond what they can enforce in their communities or via what copyright law provides. I can understand their intentions. But if you want to tackle goals beyond what can be enforced within copyright law or within your own communities, you need to use other political tools. Trying to expand the politics of Free Software will alienate people with a different political belief. So the crucial thing to understand here is, Free Software is a necessary condition for a Free Society, not sufficient. So you still need other movements and fights that goes beyond Free Software. Don't try to solve every problem in the society through copyright license alone.

Badri SunderarajanWed 18 Nov 2026 5:54AM

@Pirate Praveen regarding the last point, I agree on the premise:

Don't try to solve every problem in the society through copyright license alone.

However, there are two approaches to this:

  1. Expand the Free Software movement using tools other than copyright licence

  2. Stick to copyright licence as a tool and limit ourselves to problems we can solve using that tool

I think many of the debates we've had in the group chat boil down to whether we want the Free Software movement take approach (1) or (2). Many people have a lot of additional assumptions about the philosophy of the Free Software movement or some of the projects within it beyond what was stated when the movement was started.

AkshayWed 18 Nov 2026 6:57AM

@Badri Sunderarajan What I've understood in trying to do 1 is that practically it is very very difficult. Free software communities are not filled with allies of larger political goals. I also realize this is because there's no larger philosophy against class, caste etc in free software movement. Without such foundational analyses of society, I've found it difficult to even ally with people who appear like they're for progressive change.

Badri SunderarajanWed 18 Nov 2026 7:20AM

@Akshay Free Software communities may not be filled with allies of larger political goals, but some of their supporters are, and get disappointed when they realise Free Software does not fill those goals.

Example: LibreOffice was boosted all over the Fedi for marketing itself as not having "AI" features. Later, when it turned out they use LLMs to write their own code, their marketing was taken to be dishonest/a betrayal. Why? Even though LibreOffice never explicitly said they were against using LLMs at all, the people who shared the post and later felt betrayed assumed they had such a philosophy.

Similarly, many software that may be considered great from a purely Free Software perspective such as Ladybird and Omarcy are seen as problematic for other, political reasons (very different from the emacs vs. vi wars for example).

I think cyberspace is ripe with people ready to support a broader political movement related to software—there just doesn't exist a coherent movement for them to support yet, due to which they end up supporting things like Open Source and Free Software hoping it takes care of their other goals too and then get disappointed and disillusioned when it doesn't.

Practical questions:

  • How much overlap is there among the philosophies of these "Free Software but more" supporters? Are there significant areas of alignment that could be used as the basis of a new movement

  • If there is such a "common minimum philosophy", how compatible is it with the current Free Software philosophy? Specifically, can software developed under that philosophy be shared with the Free Software movement? (Example: licence-based movements like the Anticapitalist Software Licence can't really collaborate with the Free Software movement as it stands, but the Permacomputing movement whose principles the FSCI adopted when nobody noticed might be able to, and the LLM-powered OccupySaaS movement certainly can.)

  • If there is a reasonable level of compatibility with the current Free Software movement, then how many of those in the latter (or, specifically, within FSCI) are interested in that "common minimum philosophy"? (Based on this, we could either expand/fork or start that as a separate, distinct movement using Free Software as a base or component)

Pirate PraveenWed 18 Nov 2026 7:27AM

@Akshay So there are two approaches here,

1.We need separate movements for specific issues like Free Software and larger politics. I tried to do that with Indian Pirates, but it did not get much support. Those who want to extend Free Software are not necessarily interested in doing this as a larger banner as that is even more work and without much shorter term success.

2. You can have Free Software groups tied with larger political goals like FSMK, DAKF, VGLUG etc There Free Software ideas are secondary to social goals. It has its own issues like people not really serious about Free Software philosophy. It ends up more like an avenue to place leaders from CPIM/SFI etc above community. Remotely controlled by the parent political party. As a way to indirectly organize workers since using CPIM banner directly may be resisted. It has its own issues of lacking transparency and independence.