COllaborative DEcision MAking (codema.in)

Create and maintain a page on FSCI website for laptops and phones which can run fully free software

Ravi Dwivedi Fri 12 Mar 2021 6:22AMPublicSeen by 51

Last date to comment: 19-March-2021

Maintain a page on FSCI website listing laptops and phones which can run fully free software. That would raise awareness among people on which laptops/phones respect their freedom.

Criteria: Hardware should be able to run a Free/Libre operating system without any proprietary blobs. Devices should also preferably have a free system firmware - like coreboot or libreboot with hardware backdoors disabled if present like the Intel ME backdoor.

List of mobile phones:

Laptops:

Honorable Mentions:

Gitlab issue is here https://gitlab.com/fsci/fsci.gitlab.io/-/issues/11

Abraham RajiWed 17 Mar 2021 2:12PM

What's the progress regarding this?

AkhilThu 18 Mar 2021 1:15PM

Just noticed this. Is the criteria - run a fsf certified distro wtihout pain ?
If yes, then remove Star LabTop Mk IV from the list. Requires proprietary firmware for connectivity and updated proprietary firmware for storage controller. There may be more proprietary firmware involved.

AkhilThu 18 Mar 2021 2:27PM

Since it's FSCI, we should be recommending hardware able to run a Free/Libre OS without any proprietary blobs. Devices should also preferably have a free system firmware - like coreboot or libreboot with hardware backdoors disabled if present.

In the list above, Star LabTop Mk IV does not satisfy this criterion, the others do.

mujeebcpyFri 19 Mar 2021 7:46AM

it is good. i have another suggestion. it is difficult to get a laptop which supports wifi or other drivers. (including proprietary drivers) so an initiative to list gnulinux supported devices will be good. including printers